Analyse how far PM-JANMAN and the Dharti Aaba Janjatiya Gram Utkarsh Abhiyan have moved from scheme-based to saturation-based tribal development. What implementation challenges remain?
New · District CollectorCan you hold the district for 72 hours?Floods, a heatwave, an outbreak, a grievance queue. Take the decisions, see the consequences.Play →In this answer
Saturation means giving every eligible household or habitation the full set of basic services. Under a scheme-based approach, each scheme instead works towards its own separate target. PM-JANMAN (2023) and DAJGUA (2024) have made this shift in their design. In outcomes, the shift is so far only partial.
Design: a clear move towards saturation
- Habitation-level targeting: PM-JANMAN covers PVTG habitations, which are the most deprived. Its outlay is ₹24,104 crore [1].
- Convergence: DAJGUA delivers 25 interventions through 17 line ministries. Its outlay is ₹79,156 crore and it covers about 63,000 tribal-majority villages [2].
- Scale and intent: together the two schemes carry more than ₹1 lakh crore. They follow a "last-first" principle, under which families that were served last are now to be served first [3].
- Community participation: the Dharti Aaba Janbhagidari Abhiyan brings people into delivery [3].
Outcomes: progress is partial
- By November 2025, about 50% of sanctioned houses (2.38 lakh of 4.71 lakh) were complete. Only about 12% of roads (825 of 6,951 km) and 328 of 1,000 Multi-Purpose Centres were finished [4].
- Another 100 centres opened on Janjatiya Gaurav Diwas 2026 [3]. Overall, building assets is moving faster than connecting habitations to them.
Implementation challenges
- Unreliable baseline: States counted PVTGs on the PM Gati Shakti app, and the Ministry itself calls the figures an estimate [5]. A habitation missed in the survey drops out of every target, so the scheme can report "saturation" while those families get nothing.
- Gap in convergence: the Tribal Affairs Ministry's own DAJGUA allocation was only ₹2,000 crore in 2025-26 [6]. Most of the money sits in other ministries' budgets, and the nodal ministry cannot set their priorities.
- Fiscal federalism: States must pay ₹22,823 crore under DAJGUA [2] and ₹8,768 crore under PM-JANMAN [1]. States with weak finances can stall delivery.
- Terrain: PVTG habitations are small, scattered and often in forest areas. Roads there need forest-land clearances and hard construction, and health, ration and school access depend on those roads.
- Measuring inputs rather than results: progress is reported as sanctions and launches, not as service levels reached by each household.
The two missions have changed tribal policy from scattered schemes to convergent, habitation-based saturation, but the gaps in delivery are still large. The way forward is a verified household-level baseline, a convergence dashboard that holds each line ministry accountable, fast-tracked forest clearances for roads, and outcome indicators. These steps would give real effect to Article 46 and to the SDG pledge to "leave no one behind".
Sources
- 1PIB, *Janjatiya Gaurav Divas: Celebrating Tribal Heritage*PM-JANMAN for PVTGs; ₹24,104 crore outlay and the State share
- 2PIB, *PM launches Dharti Aaba Janjatiya Gram Utkarsh Abhiyan from Hazaribagh*DAJGUA's 25 interventions, 17 ministries, ₹79,156 crore outlay, ~63,000 villages and ₹22,823 crore State share
- 3PIB, Janjatiya Gaurav Diwas 2026 press releasemore than ₹1 lakh crore combined, "last-first" principle, Janbhagidari Abhiyan, 100 Multi-Purpose Centres opened
- 4PIB, Ministry of Tribal Affairs: progress under PM-JANMAN (Dec 2025)houses, roads and Multi-Purpose Centres completed by Nov 2025
- 5PIB, *Progress under PM JANMAN for development of PVTGs*PVTG count through the PM Gati Shakti app, called an estimate
- 6PIB, *Empowering Tribes Towards Viksit Bharat: Union Budget 2025*Tribal Affairs Ministry's DAJGUA allocation raised from ₹500 crore to ₹2,000 crore