·PIB·15 marks·250–350 words

Assess how effective the Commission for Air Quality Management has been as a statutory body for inter-State airshed governance. Suggest reforms.

New · District CollectorCan you hold the district for 72 hours?Floods, a heatwave, an outbreak, a grievance queue. Take the decisions, see the consequences.Play →
In this answer
  1. Effectiveness: Gains
  2. Effectiveness: Limitations
  3. Reforms

The CAQM Act, 2021 set up a statutory body that is the sole authority on air quality for Delhi and the adjoining areas of Haryana, Punjab, Rajasthan and UP [2]. It is India's first regulator for a whole airshed. Its record is mixed: it coordinates well but enforces weakly.

Effectiveness: Gains

  • Unified command: it replaced EPCA. Its orders override those of State authorities where they conflict, and appeals go to the NGT [2].
  • Data-driven GRAP: the Sub-Committee on GRAP invokes and revokes stages based on AQI trends and IMD/IITM forecasts. For example, it lifted Stage III at AQI 204 on 17.11.2026 [1].
  • Standing orders beyond GRAP: the dust-control order of 30.10.2026 stayed in force after Stage III was lifted [1].
  • Stubble outcomes: Punjab recorded 5,114 farm fires in 2025, 53% fewer than in 2024. Haryana recorded 662 [5].

Effectiveness: Limitations

  • Reactive cycle: Stage III was revoked on 14.11.2022 and brought back on 04.12.2022 [3]. Even with fewer farm fires, it was needed again in November 2026 [1].
  • Enforcement gap: State police, municipal bodies and pollution control boards carry out CAQM's directions. In 2018 a Standing Committee flagged weak enforcement by Haryana, Punjab and UP [7]. In 2025 a Standing Committee was still asking for named agencies and penalties [6].
  • Weak data base: CAG found that vehicles cause 39% of Delhi's PM2.5. Yet there was no vehicle emission inventory, and several monitoring stations were badly placed [4].

Reforms

  • Airshed-wide enforcement: one shared plan, with the same penalties in every State [6].
  • Clear accountability: a named agency for every direction, with regular inspections [6].
  • Better science: build emission inventories, move badly placed stations and upgrade them to real-time CAAQMS [4][6].
  • Target-based planning: revise the NAAQS toward WHO targets so that GRAP sits inside a long-term plan to cut emissions [6].
  • Own field capacity: CAQM enforcement cells in each district, so it depends less on State staff.

CAQM has given the NCR a single legal voice on air, but it still mostly manages emergencies rather than cutting emissions. A target-based plan for the whole airshed with clear accountability, as the Standing Committee urges, can make it a model of cooperative federalism and protect the Article 21 right to clean air.

Sources

  1. 1PIB, Ministry of Environment, Forest and Climate Change: CAQM revokes GRAP Stage III in Delhi-NCR (17.11.2026)role of the Sub-Committee, IMD/IITM inputs, AQI 204, the 30.10.2026 dust order continuing, Stage III back in November 2026
  2. 2PRS Bill Track: CAQM in NCR and Adjoining Areas Bill, 2021sole-authority status, jurisdiction over four States, EPCA dissolved, primacy over State bodies, NGT appeals
  3. 3PIB: GRAP Stage III re-invoked in NCR (December 2022)revoke-and-reinvoke cycle in 2022
  4. 4CAG Report No. 2 of 2022: Performance Audit on Prevention and Mitigation of Vehicular Air Pollution in Delhivehicles' 39% share of PM2.5, no emission inventory, badly placed monitoring stations
  5. 5PIB: Paddy Harvesting Season 2025 concludes with significant Reduction in Farm Fire Incidents across Punjab and Haryana5,114 Punjab fires (53% fewer than 2024), 662 in Haryana
  6. 6PRS Report Summary: Air Pollution in Delhi NCR and steps taken by various agencies for its mitigation (Standing Committee, 2025)airshed-level enforcement, named agencies and penalties, CAAQMS upgrade, NAAQS revision
  7. 7PRS Report Summary: Air Pollution in Delhi and National Capital Region (Standing Committee, 2018)weak enforcement by Haryana, Punjab and UP

More from this note