Bihar is adding both coal-based and solar capacity. Critically evaluate this dual-track approach in the context of India's energy-transition commitments.
New · District CollectorCan you hold the district for 72 hours?Floods, a heatwave, an outbreak, a grievance queue. Take the decisions, see the consequences.Play →In this answer
Bihar was once a power-deficit state, and many of its villages had no electricity. Its recent package now includes the coal-based Buxar Thermal Power Plant, a solar plant at Phulwaria Dam and the Pirpainti transmission system [1]. At the same time, India has committed to non-fossil capacity targets and net zero by 2070 [2]. Bihar's dual track can be defended as a bridge, but only if it has an end date.
Merits of the dual track
- Energy security and firm power: Solar output varies with the time of day and the weather. Thermal power supports promised 12-hour irrigation supply and new industry such as the Gayaji steel project [1].
- National targets have room for a lagging state: India reached 50% non-fossil installed capacity in 2025, five years ahead of its NDC target [2]. A low-consumption state adding some coal does not breach India's commitment. This follows the principle of equity and CBDR-RC (common but differentiated responsibilities and respective capabilities).
- Grid readiness: The Pirpainti transmission line strengthens evacuation (carrying power from plants to the grid). That helps future renewable power reach users [1].
- Diversification: Phulwaria solar starts a renewable portfolio instead of relying on coal alone [1].
Concerns
- Carbon lock-in: Thermal plants run for decades. Coal capacity built now may become a stranded asset as the 2070 net-zero deadline approaches.
- Fiscal stress: Bihar's own revenue is below the median state, so it depends on central transfers [3]. Its fiscal deficit was revised to 11.8% of GSDP in 2025-26, against a 3% budget target, and power subsidy was one reason for higher revenue spending [4]. Costly thermal tariffs could deepen this burden.
- Environmental cost: Coal plants add to air pollution in the already polluted Indo-Gangetic plain and draw heavily on water.
- Imbalance: Solar may stay a token addition while coal carries the main load.
Way forward
- Schedule the retirement of old units and run thermal plants flexibly, so they back up renewables rather than displace them.
- Scale up PM-KUSUM solar pumps, rooftop solar and battery storage to absorb daytime solar.
Overall, the dual track meets Bihar's real need for affordable, reliable power, but it carries climate and fiscal risks. Coal should be time-bound and solar should grow quickly. That would let Bihar meet SDG-7 (affordable and clean energy) and support India's net-zero goal.
Sources
- 1PIB: PM inaugurates and lays foundation stones for projects worth ~Rs. 34,470 crore in Vaishali, BiharBihar's power-deficit past; Buxar thermal, Phulwaria Dam solar and Pirpainti transmission; 12-hour irrigation power; Gayaji steel project
- 2PIB: India's Renewable Rise – Non-Fossil Sources Now Power Half the Nation's Grid (July 2025)50% non-fossil capacity reached five years ahead of the NDC target; net-zero context
- 3NITI Aayog: Macro and Fiscal Landscape of the State of Bihar (March 2025)own revenue below the median state; dependence on central transfers
- 4PRS Legislative Research: Bihar Budget Analysis 2026-272025-26 revised fiscal deficit of 11.8% of GSDP against a 3% target; power subsidy behind higher revenue spending