·The Hindu·15 marks·250–350 words

Can cultural and civilisational engagement help India balance China's influence within the SCO? Critically analyse.

New · District CollectorCan you hold the district for 72 hours?Floods, a heatwave, an outbreak, a grievance queue. Take the decisions, see the consequences.Play →
In this answer
  1. How cultural engagement helps India
  2. Limits
  3. Way forward

PM Modi proposed a Civilisational Dialogue Forum at the 25th SCO Summit in Tianjin (2025) to strengthen people-to-people ties [2]. Its first edition now opens at Purana Qila, New Delhi. It is India's bid to shape an Asian identity in which China takes part but does not dominate. It is a useful lever, but a limited one.

How cultural engagement helps India

  • Agenda-setting: India is not a founding member. Even so, it proposed the forum on Chinese soil and is hosting it, and the India–Russia Joint Statement recorded that the inaugural session would be held in India [3].
  • Low-friction track: The SCO works by consensus. The Qingdao Defence Ministers' meeting produced no agreed outcome document because members could not reach consensus [4]. A culture forum asks no one to sign texts on terrorism or borders, so few members have reason to block it.
  • Civilisational narrative: Purana Qila has Sher Shah Suri's walls above traditional Indraprastha. The venue projects plural continuity and challenges a China-centred reading of "shared SCO civilisation".
  • Bridge role: The forum fits the "Opportunity" pillar of India's Security–Connectivity–Opportunity vision [1]. It also links Central Asia and the Global South, which supports India's strategic autonomy.

Limits

  • Asymmetry of resources: China's weight rests on money and institutions, such as the Beijing Secretariat and the proposed SCO Development Bank. A non-binding forum brings no loans or roads.
  • Event, not institution: The forum has no secretariat, budget or rotation yet.
  • Shared stage: Because China attends, it can help shape what "SCO civilisation" means.
  • Hard issues need hard diplomacy: India's terrorism concerns were won at leader level, when the Tianjin Declaration condemned the Pahalgam attack [1]. Culture did not deliver that.

Way forward

  • Write the forum into the next summit declaration, and fix a rotating host and a joint heritage-research output.
  • Pair it with concrete offers such as Chabahar and INSTC connectivity [1] and ICCR scholarships.
  • Keep the forum's agenda clear of disputes, in line with the "development partners, not rivals" understanding with China [5].

Cultural engagement cannot match China's economic weight on its own. It does give India low-cost standing and some control of the agenda in a grouping prone to deadlock. If it is made permanent and backed by connectivity and development offers, it can help keep the SCO plural and multipolar, balancing China without trying to contain it.

Sources

  1. 1New India Samachar, 1–15 October 2025 (PIB): Security–Connectivity–Opportunity pillars; Chabahar/INSTC; Tianjin Declaration condemning Pahalgam
  2. 2MEA Annual Report 2025: PM's proposal of an SCO Civilisational Dialogue Forum for people-to-people ties
  3. 3Joint Statement, 23rd India–Russia Annual Summit, 5 Dec 2025 (MEA): inaugural forum session to be held in India in 2026
  4. 4MEA, Rajya Sabha Question No. 567: Exclusion of Pahalgam Terror Attack from SCO Declaration: no agreed Qingdao outcome document because of no consensus
  5. 5PIB: Prime Minister's bilateral meeting with President Xi Jinping (Tianjin, 2025): India and China as "development partners, not rivals"

More from this note