·PIB·15 marks·250–350 words

How can shared cultural and philosophical heritage strengthen India's engagement with Eurasia? Discuss its potential and limits.

New · District CollectorCan you hold the district for 72 hours?Floods, a heatwave, an outbreak, a grievance queue. Take the decisions, see the consequences.Play →
In this answer
  1. Potential
  2. Limits

India proposed a civilisational dialogue platform at the SCO Tianjin Summit (2025), and the Bishkek Declaration welcomed it. The result is the First SCO Civilisational Dialogue Forum, held at Purana Qila from 20 to 22 November 2026 [1]. Shared heritage can add a cultural layer to India's Eurasian outreach, but it has clear limits.

Potential

  • Agenda-setting: an Indian proposal became an SCO outcome. This shows India shaping the grouping's agenda, not just reacting to it [1].
  • Shared strands of heritage: the forum's four sessions cover performing arts, textiles and cuisine; art and architecture; scripts and manuscripts; and monastic trails and philosophical traditions [1]. Monastic trails recall the Buddhist links with Central Asia along the Silk Routes.
  • People-to-people ties: the participants are scholars, academics and cultural representatives, not only officials [1].
  • Normative frame: the theme Vasudhaiva Kutumbakam offers an inclusive, pluralist alternative to "clash of civilisations" thinking [1].
  • Low-friction track: culture lets members keep meeting even when they disagree on security.

Limits

  • Cannot settle hard disputes: the participants cannot commit their governments, and no outcome document has been named [1]. Terrorism and border issues stay untouched, and cultural exchanges are often the first to be suspended when ties sour.
  • Competing narratives: China leads a parallel track at the UN. Its Permanent Mission hosted the first observance of the International Day for Dialogue among Civilizations, created by resolution A/RES/78/286 [2]. The real contest is over whose idea of "civilisation" sets the terms.
  • "Shared" theme, national display: both the ASTITVA exhibition and the Mahabharat Scroll Pavilion show Indian heritage [1]. Partner countries may see this as India showcasing itself.
  • No institutional cycle: the UN Alliance of Civilizations has lasted because it meets regularly; its 11th Global Forum was held in Riyadh in 2025 [3]. The SCO forum has no rotating host or fixed schedule yet.

Shared heritage gives India a credible soft-power entry into Eurasia, but it complements security cooperation and cannot replace it. The forum could become a lasting SCO platform with a rotating host written into the next declaration, exhibitions co-curated with partner countries, and outcome documents listing joint projects such as manuscript digitisation. Linking it to the UN's civilisational-dialogue track instead of rivalling it would help. That would turn Vasudhaiva Kutumbakam from a theme into practice.

Sources

  1. 1Press Information Bureau: "PM to inaugurate First SCO Civilisational Dialogue Forum on 20 November"Tianjin proposal, Bishkek welcome, venue and dates, sessions, participants, theme, ASTITVA and Scroll Pavilion
  2. 2United Nations: International Day for Dialogue among Civilizationsresolution A/RES/78/286; China's Permanent Mission hosted the first observance
  3. 3UN News: Dialogue is 'not naïve – it's necessary' as global divisions deepen, UN Riyadh forum hears (Dec 2025)UNAOC's 11th Global Forum in Riyadh
Practice
Questions on this item
Check the answer for each question, or reveal all at once.
Practice MCQs →

More from this note