·The Hindu·15 marks·250–350 words

The collapse of the JCPOA illustrates the fragility of multilateral non-proliferation arrangements. Examine, with reference to the 2026 U.S.–Iran conflict.

New · District CollectorCan you hold the district for 72 hours?Floods, a heatwave, an outbreak, a grievance queue. Take the decisions, see the consequences.Play →
In this answer
  1. Why the arrangement proved fragile
  2. How the 2026 conflict exposes the cost
  3. Way forward

The Joint Comprehensive Plan of Action (2015) was endorsed by UNSC Resolution 2231. Under it, Iran accepted limits on its nuclear programme in return for sanctions relief. The deal began to unravel with the U.S. exit in 2018, and in the 2026 war it broke down completely. This shows that a multilateral non-proliferation deal lasts only as long as the major powers choose to honour it.

Why the arrangement proved fragile

  • Compliance did not ensure survival: in 2018 the IAEA confirmed Iran was keeping its commitments and called the deal a "significant verification gain" [1]. The U.S. still walked out.
  • Narrow scope: the deal covered only nuclear activity. The U.S. gave Iran's ballistic missile programme as its reason for leaving [2].
  • No remedy against defection: Iran called the re-imposed sanctions a "flagrant violation" of Res 2231 [2]. No mechanism could hold a permanent UNSC member to account.
  • Executive, not treaty, commitment: a single U.S. administration could undo it.

How the 2026 conflict exposes the cost

  • Verification blind spot: the IAEA cannot verify about 440 kg of 60% enriched uranium. Normal inspections have stopped everywhere except Bushehr [3].
  • Diplomacy tied to access: a June 2026 U.S.–Iran understanding allowed technical work to begin [4]. The IAEA chief now says inspectors can return only when negotiations resume [3].
  • Divided Security Council: Russia and China dispute whether the "snapback" sanctions under Res 2231 are legal [5]. The UN therefore cannot fill the gap.
  • Coercion over bargaining: war and a naval blockade have replaced a rules-based deal. This strengthens the argument in Tehran that only a deterrent can guarantee its security.

Way forward

  • JCPOA-plus: restore the nuclear limits first, then negotiate missiles and regional issues in a separate track.
  • Durable guarantees: Council-backed commitments, with sanctions relief phased in as IAEA milestones are met.
  • Inspections first: make the return of IAEA access the first confidence-building step.
  • Middle powers: back regional mediation such as Qatar's. India has energy and Chabahar stakes in the region and should publicly support the IAEA's return.

The JCPOA collapsed because political commitment failed, not because verification did. A wider, guaranteed and verifiable deal, anchored in the NPT and Res 2231, would best restore the credibility of multilateral non-proliferation and support peace in West Asia.

Sources

  1. 1UN News: "Iran deal represents 'significant verification gain' – UN atomic energy chief" (May 2018)IAEA confirmation of Iranian compliance; "significant verification gain"
  2. 2UN Security Council press releases on JCPOA / Resolution 2231 (2018)U.S. ballistic-missile rationale for exit; Iran's "flagrant violation of resolution 2231" claim
  3. 3UN News: World News in Brief — IAEA calls for Iran nuclear inspections (Oct 2026)~440 kg 60% enriched uranium unverified; inspections only at Bushehr; return of inspectors tied to talks
  4. 4UN News: "US-Iran deal: Technical work can begin, says atomic energy agency" (Jun 2026)June 2026 understanding allowing technical work
  5. 5UN Press: Security Council debates Iran nuclear programme amid dispute over 'snapback' sanctions (SC/16316)Russia and China challenge the legality of snapback

More from this note