·The Hindu·15 marks·250–350 words

Data deficiency is itself a conservation threat. Comment, with examples of poorly studied endemic species of the Andaman & Nicobar Islands.

New · District CollectorCan you hold the district for 72 hours?Floods, a heatwave, an outbreak, a grievance queue. Take the decisions, see the consequences.Play →
In this answer
  1. How data deficiency becomes a threat
  2. Poorly studied endemics of A&N Islands
  3. A caveat

A species that has not been counted is hard to protect. The Andaman cobra (Naja sagittifera) is India's only island-dwelling cobra. More than a century after Frank Wall described it in 1913, it is still poorly studied [1]. This lack of knowledge is not neutral: it makes extinction more likely.

How data deficiency becomes a threat

  • Vicious cycle: With no population or range data, a species gets no clear threat category. Low priority brings little funding, and little funding keeps it unstudied.
  • Legal blind spot: The Wild Life (Protection) Act lists cobras as "All species of the Genus Naja" [5]. So a rare island endemic gets the same protection as widespread mainland cobras. The 2022 amendment cut the animal schedules to two [3]. The Parliamentary Standing Committee pointed out that some species were left out of the schedules and others put in the wrong one [4].
  • Unmonitored decline: In small populations, inbreeding can cause birth defects and poor fertility. Along with deforestation and farm expansion, this damage goes on without being measured [1].
  • No backup population: The species lives nowhere else, so restocking from outside is impossible [1]. A mistake made because data was missing cannot be undone later.
  • Human side also unmeasured: Official estimates put snakebite deaths at about 50,000 a year, but records show only about 2,000, so the problem is heavily under-reported [6]. Fear of a venom-spitting snake leads people to kill it [1].

Poorly studied endemics of A&N Islands

  • Andaman cobra: Its ecology is barely documented. It is threatened by fear-driven killing and shrinking habitat [1].
  • Narcondam hornbill, Nicobar megapode, island shrews and reptiles: The ZSI says isolation explains the islands' high endemism [2]. But many of these species are known mainly from taxonomic surveys, not long-term population monitoring.

A caveat

  • Missing data must not become a reason to wait. Habitat loss and conflict killing are already known threats, so precautionary action is justified now [1].

Data deficiency multiplies the risks that small island endemics already face. The way forward is systematic ZSI/WII field surveys, separate legal listing for endemics as the Standing Committee urged [4], and NAPSE's One Health approach to reduce fear-driven killing [6]. Together with in-situ habitat protection, closing the knowledge gap would serve SDG 15 (Life on Land).

Sources

  1. 1India's sole island-dwelling cobra faces conservation challenges, The Hindu, Sci-Tech/Environment (18 Nov 2026)description in 1913, poor study, inbreeding, deforestation, fear-killing, no outside population (link goes to the section page because the article itself could not be reached)
  2. 2Zoological Survey of India — Endemic Fauna of Andaman and Nicobar Islandsisolation driving high endemism; documented island endemics
  3. 3PRS Bill Summary — The Wild Life (Protection) Amendment Bill, 2021animal schedules cut to two
  4. 4PRS Standing Committee Report Summary — Wild Life (Protection) Amendment Bill, 2021species left out of or wrongly placed in the schedules
  5. 5Wild Life (Protection) Act, 1972 — Schedules, India Code"All species of the Genus Naja" listed as one entry (link goes to the India Code home page because the schedule page could not be checked)
  6. 6PIB — Union Health Ministry launches National Action Plan for Prevention and Control of Snakebite Envenomingestimated vs recorded deaths, One Health approach

More from this note