·The Hindu·15 marks·250–350 wordsHistoryIRDefence

Declarations that 'a nuclear war cannot be won and must never be fought' are normatively significant but practically hollow without verification. Analyse.

New · District CollectorCan you hold the district for 72 hours?Floods, a heatwave, an outbreak, a grievance queue. Take the decisions, see the consequences.Play →
In this answer
  1. Normative significance
  2. Practical hollowness
  3. Why verification is the key
  4. Way forward

Reagan and Gorbachev first said in 1985 that "a nuclear war cannot be won and must never be fought". The P5 repeated it in January 2022 [2], and the U.S., China and Russia repeated it again at Shenzhen in November 2026 [1]. The formula has real value as a norm. Without verification, though, it binds no one.

Normative significance

  • Shared taboo: The three largest nuclear powers jointly reject nuclear war-fighting, which makes first-strike doctrines harder to justify.
  • Diplomatic opening: At Shenzhen the line came with a commitment to a dialogue on reducing nuclear risks [1]. That draws China into a nuclear forum alongside the U.S. and Russia.
  • Yardstick for accountability: Smaller states and the UN can hold the powers to their own words. The UN Secretary-General has already urged a successor framework to New START [4].

Practical hollowness

  • Words vs conduct: About a year after the P5 statement, Russia suspended New START (February 2023) [3].
  • Legal vacuum: New START expired in February 2026. There are now no legally binding limits on U.S. and Russian arsenals [3].
  • No numbers: The Shenzhen declaration sets no caps, no timeline and no inspections [1].
  • Unequal arsenals: China has never allowed foreign inspection of its strategic forces. Equal ceilings would also suit no one, because the three arsenals are so different in size.

Why verification is the key

Declaration (norm) → Data exchange → Inspections → Binding limits → Stability

Fig.: How intent becomes restraint that others can check

  • New START's data exchanges, notifications and on-site inspections turned trust into facts each side could check [3]. Without them, each side plans for the worst, and that feeds an arms race.
  • India's stake: India's credible minimum deterrence is set against China's arsenal. India wants disarmament that is universal, non-discriminatory and verifiable, and has proposed this through CD/1816 at the Conference on Disarmament [5].

Way forward

The formula sets the goal, and verification is what gets the powers there. A phased roadmap would give the declaration teeth:

  • restore U.S.–Russia data exchanges;
  • get China to declare its warhead numbers;
  • then agree counting rules and inspections.

India should keep pushing for a Fissile Material Cut-off Treaty at the Conference on Disarmament [5]. Together these steps would turn a moral consensus into checkable restraint, in line with SDG 16 and the UN Charter's commitment to peace.

Sources

  1. 1U.S.–Russia–China Heads of State Declaration toward Peace, The White House (Nov 2026): Shenzhen restatement of "cannot be won"; dialogue on reducing nuclear risks; no caps or verification
  2. 2Joint Statement of the Leaders of the Five Nuclear-Weapon States on Preventing Nuclear War and Avoiding Arms Races, GOV.UK (3 Jan 2022): P5 restatement of the formula
  3. 3UN chief warns of 'grave moment' as final US-Russia nuclear arms treaty expires, UN News (Feb 2026): expiry; no binding limits; Russia's 2023 suspension; data exchanges, notifications and inspections
  4. 4Statement by the Secretary-General on the expiration of the New START Treaty, 5 Feb 2026): call for a successor framework
  5. 5Disarmament and International Security Affairs Overview, Ministry of External Affairs: India's position on universal, non-discriminatory, verifiable disarmament; CD/1816; FMCT
Practice
8 questions on this article
Check the answer for each question, or reveal all at once.
Practice MCQs →

More from this note

More on History