·The Hindu·15 marks·250–350 words

Discuss the challenges a national party faces in reviving itself in States where regional parties are now its senior allies.

New · District CollectorCan you hold the district for 72 hours?Floods, a heatwave, an outbreak, a grievance queue. Take the decisions, see the consequences.Play →
In this answer
  1. Organisational challenges
  2. Electoral challenges
  3. Alliance-management challenges
  4. The other side

In India's first-past-the-post system, a divided opposition vote helps the leading party. This pushes national parties into pre-poll pacts in which they are the junior partner. The Congress plays that role with the SP in Uttar Pradesh's 403-seat Assembly [1], with the RJD in Bihar and with the DMK in Tamil Nadu. Joining such an alliance protects the opposition vote, but it also limits the national party's own room to grow.

Organisational challenges

  • Ceded seats mean ceded cadre: where the party fields no candidate, its workers have no one to campaign for and drift to the ally or the rival.
  • Leadership drain: ambitious local leaders move to whichever party can give them a ticket, so the national party's bench grows thin.
  • Senior partner absorbs the base: over several elections the regional party turns the junior partner's voters into its own.

Electoral challenges

  • Revival vs winnability: asking for more seats can help the party grow. Under FPTP, though, a weak candidate loses seats the stronger partner could have won.
  • Vote transfer is not automatic: regional parties rest on caste and community coalitions, and many of these groups left the Congress in the Hindi heartland after the Mandal period. Leaders can sign a deal in the capital, but voters on the ground will not necessarily follow it.

Alliance-management challenges

  • Delayed seat-sharing: in Bihar's 2025 polls, the Mahagathbandhan was still disputing seats into the nomination phase [2]. This cut short the joint campaign and blurred its message.
  • No legal glue: the Tenth Schedule disqualifies individual defectors but does not bind alliances [3]. The Law Commission's 170th Report suggested treating pre-poll fronts as one unit under anti-defection law [4], but this has not been adopted.

The other side

  • Being the junior partner is not fatal. The Congress has stayed relevant in Tamil Nadu for decades as the DMK's ally. The 2024 SP–Congress Lok Sabha understanding in UP also showed that pooled votes pay off.

Overall, the national party is caught between growing its own organisation and keeping the alliance strong. The way forward is to allocate seats by winnability data and fix early deadlines. Partners should also agree on a written common programme, as the UPA did with its 2004 Common Minimum Programme. Real revival comes from building cadre between elections, not from pressing for extra seats on the eve of polls. Done this way, a national party can still grow, and competition stays healthy in India's federal, multi-party democracy.

Sources

  1. 1PRS Legislative Research — Profile of the 18th Uttar Pradesh Legislative AssemblyUP Assembly strength of 403 seats
  2. 2All India Radio News — "Bihar Elections: Mahagathbandhan struggles with seat-sharing discord" (19 Oct 2025)delayed, disputed seat-sharing in Bihar 2025
  3. 3Constitution of India, Tenth Schedule — Legislative Department, Ministry of Law and Justiceanti-defection law applies to individual legislators
  4. 4Law Commission of India — 170th Report on Reform of the Electoral Laws (1999), Electoral Reforms sectiontreating pre-poll fronts as a unit under anti-defection law

More from this note