·The Hindu·15 marks·250–350 words

Discuss the merits and challenges of taxing unrealised capital gains on an accrual basis. Should India consider such a model?

New · District CollectorCan you hold the district for 72 hours?Floods, a heatwave, an outbreak, a grievance queue. Take the decisions, see the consequences.Play →
In this answer
  1. Merits
  2. Challenges
  3. Should India adopt it?

Accrual-basis taxation charges tax each year on the rise in an asset's value, even if the asset is not sold. India taxes capital gains only on sale (realisation basis). The Netherlands is moving its "Box 3" savings tax to an accrual model. It is doing so because its Supreme Court struck down the old assumed-return system in 2021 as violating property rights [1]. For India, the model has merit, but only in a limited form.

Merits

  • Ends deferral: when gains are taxed only on sale, owners can hold assets and put off tax for years. Wealth that is never sold may never be taxed.
  • Neutrality: the IMF says Box 3 reform would align investment incentives by taxing capital income consistently [2]. The OECD urges faster actual-return taxation [3].
  • Fairness: tax falls on real returns, not assumed ones. This answers the Dutch court's objection [1].
  • Progressivity: the very rich hold much of their wealth as unsold gains, which an accrual tax can reach.

Challenges

  • Liquidity: tax can fall due before the owner receives any cash, which may force a sale [1].
  • Valuation: illiquid assets are hard to value every year. The Dutch therefore tax real estate and start-up shares only on sale [1].
  • Administration: for these reasons the Dutch reform has been postponed to 2028 [1].
  • Arbitrage: a mixed design draws a line between asset types, and investors may shift money to the lower-taxed side.
  • Political cost: the Dutch minority coalition split in public over its Tax Plan 2027 and then faced a no-confidence motion [4].

Should India adopt it?

  • Caution: India abolished wealth tax in 2015-16 because it cost a lot to collect and raised little. India gave up about ₹1,008 crore and expected about ₹9,000 crore from a 2% surcharge instead [5].
  • Indian constraints: wealth is concentrated in land and gold, which are hard to value. Valuation capacity is limited, and there is a litigation risk under Article 300A (right to property).
  • Calibrated path: keep realisation as the default. Consider accrual only for listed securities of very high net-worth holders, where market prices exist. Allow losses to be carried forward. Use the asset details already moved into income-tax returns [5].

Accrual taxation is fairer and more neutral, but it is hard to run and costly to pass politically. India should move step by step, with data first and a narrow scope, rather than copy the Dutch model in full. That fits the constitutional goal of preventing concentration of wealth (Article 39(c)) while keeping the tax system simple.

Sources

  1. 1IMF Country Report No. 25/197 — Kingdom of the Netherlands: 2025 Article IV Consultation (2025)2021 Supreme Court ruling; accrual design; real estate and start-up shares taxed on sale; liquidity, valuation and administration problems; delay to 2028
  2. 2IMF — Kingdom of the Netherlands: Staff Concluding Statement of the 2025 Article IV Missionspeedy Box 3 reform to align investment incentives
  3. 3OECD Economic Surveys: Netherlands 2025 — Supporting growth while preserving strong public financesspeed up actual-return Box 3 taxation
  4. 4The Hindu, "How a tax plan led the Dutch govt. to the verge of collapse" (17 Nov 2026)coalition split over the Tax Plan 2027 amendment; no-confidence motion
  5. 5Budget 2015-2016 — Speech of the Union Finance Ministerwealth tax abolished; ₹1,008 crore given up vs ₹9,000 crore from the surcharge; asset details moved into income-tax returns

More from this note