·The Hindu·15 marks·250–350 wordsS&T

Discuss the socio-medical determinants behind the rising incidence of secondary infertility in India, and evaluate the adequacy of the current regulatory framework.

In this answer
  1. Medical determinants
  2. Social determinants
  3. Evaluating the regulatory framework

The WHO defines infertility as failure to conceive after 12 months of regular unprotected intercourse; where at least one prior pregnancy was achieved, it is secondary infertility [1]. Successive National Family Health Survey rounds show its burden among currently married Indian women rising steadily since the 1990s [2], making it both a clinical and a social challenge.

Medical determinants

  • Reproductive tract infections, including sexually transmitted infections and complications of unsafe abortion or unhygienic delivery, are leading causes in developing countries [1].
  • Age-related fertility decline, as delayed marriage and wider birth spacing push the second pregnancy into the mid-thirties [2].
  • Lifestyle and NCD burden — obesity, tobacco and alcohol use, diabetes and hypertension — impairing fertility in both partners [1].

Social determinants

  • Stigma and dismissal: couples with one child are told "at least you have one", delaying care-seeking and masking prevalence.
  • Gendered blame, with women bearing diagnosis and treatment burden though male-factor causes are comparably common [1].
  • Cost and access: ART remains largely private and out-of-pocket, concentrated in metros, excluding rural and poorer households.

Evaluating the regulatory framework

  • Strengths: ICMR's non-binding 2005 guidelines were replaced by the ART (Regulation) Act, 2021 and the Surrogacy (Regulation) Act, 2021, creating enforceable standards [4]. Mandatory registration of ART clinics and banks, National and State Boards, donor age limits and penal provisions curb malpractice [3].
  • Gaps: the law regulates supply, not affordability — ART is absent from public health packages. Eligibility is confined to married couples and single women, excluding others [3]. Uneven registration, weak state-level capacity and no infertility surveillance system limit enforcement.

Secondary infertility is thus a preventable public-health problem wrapped in social silence, only partly answered by a regulation-centric law. Integrating infertility prevention into RMNCH+A, strengthening state ART authorities, and extending affordable treatment would align the framework with the reproductive rights recognised under Article 21 and SDG-3.

Sources

  1. 1WHO Fact Sheet on Infertilitydefinition of primary vs secondary infertility; infections, STIs, lifestyle and male-factor causes
  2. 2National Family Health Survey (NFHS-5), 2019–21, India Report, IIPS/MoHFWNFHS as the data source for fertility and reproductive-health trends
  3. 3The Assisted Reproductive Technology (Regulation) Act, 2021 (Act No. 42 of 2021)%20Act,%202021.pdf) — registration of clinics/banks, regulatory authorities, donor age limits, eligibility conditions
  4. 4ICMR — The ART (Regulation) Act, 2021 and the Surrogacy (Regulation) Act, 2021shift from ICMR's 2005 guidelines to binding statutes

More from this note

More on S&T