·The Hindu·15 marks·250–350 words

"An electoral roll is compromised as much by wrongful exclusion as by wrongful inclusion." Discuss in the context of recent Special Intensive Revisions.

New · District CollectorCan you hold the district for 72 hours?Floods, a heatwave, an outbreak, a grievance queue. Take the decisions, see the consequences.Play →
In this answer
  1. Wrongful inclusion: why SIRs are undertaken
  2. Wrongful exclusion: an equal harm
  3. Why exclusion can be graver
  4. Way forward

Article 326 guarantees universal adult suffrage, and Article 324 gives the ECI superintendence over electoral rolls. A roll's integrity therefore runs in two directions: it must keep out ineligible names and keep in every eligible adult. The ongoing Delhi Special Intensive Revision (SIR) shows that the second risk is as real as the first.

Wrongful inclusion: why SIRs are undertaken

  • Dead, duplicate or shifted entries open the door to impersonation and bogus voting, which distorts mandates.
  • SIRs correct this through door-to-door BLO enumeration, as in West Delhi in July 2026 [1].
  • Form 7 lets electors object to such entries. Filing it does not delete a name by itself: the ERO decides [2].

Wrongful exclusion: an equal harm

  • "Ghost" Form 7s in AC-69 Mustafabad sought to delete voters as dead, absent or shifted when they were alive and living at their recorded addresses [1].
  • Phantom objectors: the people named as objectors denied filing the forms. Of the applications the authorities examined, 37 were found false or fabricated [1].
  • Silent disenfranchisement: voters often find out only on polling day, and the burden of fixing it falls on them.
  • Targeted deletions in one locality can under-represent particular communities. The petition calls this "a crisis of electoral integrity" [1].

Why exclusion can be graver

  • An ineligible entry can still be caught at the booth through identity checks. A wrongful deletion denies the right to vote outright, and that election cannot be re-run for the voter.
  • The rules put the burden of proof on the objector [2]. Ghost filings shift that burden onto the voter.

Way forward

  • Verify objector identity, flag bulk Form 7s, and require notice and a hearing before any deletion under the Registration of Electors Rules, 1960 [2].
  • Publish deletion lists booth-wise with reasons, and prosecute false declarations under Section 31 of the RPA, 1950.
  • Judicial review through Article 32 writs, like the Mustafabad petition, works as a corrective [1].

Clean rolls and inclusive rolls are not competing goals; both are part of electoral integrity. SIRs should remove ineligible entries while protecting genuine voters, with officials held accountable for every deletion. That is how the ECI's ideal of "No voter to be left behind" and the promise of Article 326 can be met.

Sources

  1. 1Plea in SC says ghost Form 7s haunt Mustafabad constituency during Delhi SIR, *The Hindu* (news report, 17 Nov 2026)BLO enumeration in West Delhi; ghost Form 7s in AC-69 Mustafabad; phantom objectors; 37 false or fabricated applications; the writ petition. *(I could not verify the article's exact URL because the search tool cannot reach thehindu.com, so this links the site's home page.)*
  2. 2Form 7 Guidelines, Election Commission of India Voter PortalForm 7 is used to object to or delete a name; the ERO decides; burden of proof is on the applicant; framed under the Registration of Electors Rules, 1960. *(The URL is confirmed by search, but the search snippet did not show the burden-of-proof wording. That point comes from the study note.)*

More from this note