·The Hindu·15 marks·250–350 words

Evaluate translocation as a conservation tool. Can low-cost rescue models be institutionalised within India's environmental clearance framework?

New · District CollectorCan you hold the district for 72 hours?Floods, a heatwave, an outbreak, a grievance queue. Take the decisions, see the consequences.Play →
In this answer
  1. Merits of translocation
  2. Limitations
  3. Institutionalising rescue within clearances

Conservation translocation means deliberately moving organisms from one site to another [2]. In Keralam, more than 27,000 native orchids were rescued from felled highway trees, and over 71% survived after 1–2 years [1]. The project shows the tool's promise and also its limits.

Merits of translocation

  • Salvages unavoidable loss: the orchids on felled trees would otherwise have been lost; with the rescue, over 71% lived [1].
  • Plants reproduce after the move: 5,224 orchids flowered and 1,934 produced capsules (seed pods) [1].
  • Protects endemics: Keralam holds over one-third of India's 307 endemic orchids (BSI, 2019) [1].
  • Low cost and science-backed: the project is described as a low-cost model, run by RBG Kew and KSCSTE, with peer-reviewed results [1].

Limitations

  • Short test period: results cover only 1–2 years. About 3 in 10 plants died, and only about 7% formed capsules. Whether young plants establish at the new sites is unproven [1].
  • Site mismatch: moving hill orchids to salt-sprayed shores or a biopark is closer to ex situ conservation. IUCN says every translocation needs rigorous justification [2].
  • Moral hazard: "orchids saved" may make felling approvals easier, yet the host trees, which are the real habitat, are still lost.
  • Unverified cost claim: no cost per plant is reported [1].

Verdict: translocation is a valuable last resort for damage that cannot be avoided. It is not a substitute for avoiding damage.

Institutionalising rescue within clearances

  • EIA conditions: under the EIA Notification, 2006, require surveys of plants growing on trees, and their rescue, before felling. This would sit in the Environmental Management Plans of road projects in hotspots like the Western Ghats.
  • Funding: the Green Highways Policy, 2015 set aside 1% of NH project cost for plantation and transplantation [3]. Epiphyte rescue could be listed as eligible work under it.
  • Standards: adopt the IUCN 2025 guidelines on displaced organisms. They test whether a move is suitable and offer alternatives when it is not [4].
  • Accredited partners: State science councils and botanical gardens can act as rescue agencies, following the KSCSTE model [1].
  • Outcome audits: make public reporting of multi-year survival, recruitment (new young plants) and cost a condition of the clearance.

Translocation works best as the final rung of the mitigation hierarchy, after avoidance and minimisation. Low-cost rescue protocols, funded through existing green funds and audited against IUCN standards, could turn Keralam's pilot into national practice. This would advance SDG 15 and the Article 48A mandate to protect forests and wildlife.

Sources

  1. 1Keralam's orchids endure from highway trees to salt-sprayed shores, The Hindu (16 Nov 2026), citing *Diversity* 2025, 17(3), 18427,000+ orchids rescued, >71% survival, flowering and capsule counts, 307 endemics (BSI 2019), low-cost model, RBG Kew–KSCSTE partnership, coastal and biopark sites
  2. 2IUCN/SSC Guidelines for Reintroductions and Other Conservation Translocations (2013)definition of conservation translocation; need for rigorous justification
  3. 3Green Highways (Plantation, Transplantation, Beautification & Maintenance) Policy, 2015 — Ministry of Road Transport & Highways1% of NH project cost earmarked for plantation and transplantation
  4. 4IUCN Guidelines on Responsible Translocation of Displaced Organisms (2025)suitability assessment and alternatives when moving displaced organisms is not feasible

More from this note