·The Hindu·15 marks·250–350 words

Examine the procedural safeguards needed before deleting electors from the rolls. How far do the ECI's recent corrective measures meet the standards of natural justice?

New · District CollectorCan you hold the district for 72 hours?Floods, a heatwave, an outbreak, a grievance queue. Take the decisions, see the consequences.Play →
In this answer
  1. Procedural safeguards needed before deletion
  2. Corrective measures: where they meet natural justice
  3. Where they fall short

Article 326 makes adult suffrage the basis of Indian democracy, and Article 324 gives the ECI control over the electoral rolls. Deleting a name takes away a citizen's vote. So it must follow audi alteram partem, the rule that no one is condemned unheard. The Special Intensive Revision (SIR) is the first intensive revision since 2003 [1]. It and the ECI's later fixes test this standard.

Procedural safeguards needed before deletion

  • Prior personal notice and hearing: except for confirmed deaths, the elector must be served a notice and given a reasonable chance to be heard [2]. Section 22 of the RP Act, 1950 requires the same.
  • Burden on the State: in Lal Babu Hussein (1995), the Supreme Court held that an existing elector cannot be removed without proper inquiry.
  • Check on bulk deletions: the ERO must personally verify deletions above 2% of an area's electors [2].
  • Reasoned, public lists: booth-wise reasons (dead, shifted, duplicate) let errors surface during claims and objections.
  • Appeal: to the DEO and then the CEO under Section 24 of the RP Act.

Corrective measures: where they meet natural justice

  • Second hearing: omitted electors in seven SIR States/UTs, including Delhi and Maharashtra, can resubmit enumeration forms. EROs decide these under Rule 21(1), Registration of Electors Rules, 1960 [3].
  • Transparency: lists of excluded electors, with probable reasons, are displayed at polling stations and on CEO websites [3].
  • Right route: after Supreme Court scrutiny, existing entries are being restored instead of forcing deleted electors to re-enrol as new voters through Form 6.

Where they fall short

  • Hearing comes after deletion: in Phase 1–2 States, names were cut first and repaired later. Natural justice requires the hearing before the adverse action.
  • Burden stays on the voter: the elector must find out about the deletion and act. People who missed the first notice are the least likely to hear of the second chance.
  • Inter-State migrants: they are the most likely to be marked "shifted", yet no dedicated route back is visible.
  • Unequal protection: how much protection a voter gets depends on which phase their State fell in.

Overall, the fixes move the ECI from "delete first" towards "hear first", but only partly. The ECI should:

  • record proof that each notice was delivered;
  • publish booth-wise deletion reasons before the rolls are final;
  • create a route back for inter-State migrants;
  • apply the same safeguards in every phase.

Then clean rolls and Article 326's promise that no voter is left behind can support each other.

Sources

  1. 1Supreme Court of India, Order dated 10 July 2025 in Diary No. 35785/2025 (challenge to ECI's SIR order, Bihar)last intensive revision of the rolls before the SIR was in 2003
  2. 2Election Commission of India, Note explaining process of annual revision/updation of electoral rolls (FAQ)notice and hearing before any deletion except deaths; ERO personal verification where deletions exceed 2%
  3. 3All India Radio News (Prasar Bharati), "EC opens fresh window for electors missing from SIR draft rolls in 7 States" (6 Nov 2026)resubmission of enumeration forms under Rule 21(1); lists of excluded electors with reasons displayed at polling stations and on CEO websites

More from this note