Examine the procedural safeguards needed before deleting electors from the rolls. How far do the ECI's recent corrective measures meet the standards of natural justice?
New · District CollectorCan you hold the district for 72 hours?Floods, a heatwave, an outbreak, a grievance queue. Take the decisions, see the consequences.Play →In this answer
Article 326 makes adult suffrage the basis of Indian democracy, and Article 324 gives the ECI control over the electoral rolls. Deleting a name takes away a citizen's vote. So it must follow audi alteram partem, the rule that no one is condemned unheard. The Special Intensive Revision (SIR) is the first intensive revision since 2003 [1]. It and the ECI's later fixes test this standard.
Procedural safeguards needed before deletion
- Prior personal notice and hearing: except for confirmed deaths, the elector must be served a notice and given a reasonable chance to be heard [2]. Section 22 of the RP Act, 1950 requires the same.
- Burden on the State: in Lal Babu Hussein (1995), the Supreme Court held that an existing elector cannot be removed without proper inquiry.
- Check on bulk deletions: the ERO must personally verify deletions above 2% of an area's electors [2].
- Reasoned, public lists: booth-wise reasons (dead, shifted, duplicate) let errors surface during claims and objections.
- Appeal: to the DEO and then the CEO under Section 24 of the RP Act.
Corrective measures: where they meet natural justice
- Second hearing: omitted electors in seven SIR States/UTs, including Delhi and Maharashtra, can resubmit enumeration forms. EROs decide these under Rule 21(1), Registration of Electors Rules, 1960 [3].
- Transparency: lists of excluded electors, with probable reasons, are displayed at polling stations and on CEO websites [3].
- Right route: after Supreme Court scrutiny, existing entries are being restored instead of forcing deleted electors to re-enrol as new voters through Form 6.
Where they fall short
- Hearing comes after deletion: in Phase 1–2 States, names were cut first and repaired later. Natural justice requires the hearing before the adverse action.
- Burden stays on the voter: the elector must find out about the deletion and act. People who missed the first notice are the least likely to hear of the second chance.
- Inter-State migrants: they are the most likely to be marked "shifted", yet no dedicated route back is visible.
- Unequal protection: how much protection a voter gets depends on which phase their State fell in.
Overall, the fixes move the ECI from "delete first" towards "hear first", but only partly. The ECI should:
- record proof that each notice was delivered;
- publish booth-wise deletion reasons before the rolls are final;
- create a route back for inter-State migrants;
- apply the same safeguards in every phase.
Then clean rolls and Article 326's promise that no voter is left behind can support each other.
Sources
- 1Supreme Court of India, Order dated 10 July 2025 in Diary No. 35785/2025 (challenge to ECI's SIR order, Bihar)last intensive revision of the rolls before the SIR was in 2003
- 2Election Commission of India, Note explaining process of annual revision/updation of electoral rolls (FAQ)notice and hearing before any deletion except deaths; ERO personal verification where deletions exceed 2%
- 3All India Radio News (Prasar Bharati), "EC opens fresh window for electors missing from SIR draft rolls in 7 States" (6 Nov 2026)resubmission of enumeration forms under Rule 21(1); lists of excluded electors with reasons displayed at polling stations and on CEO websites