How far can people-centric cultural diplomacy offset strategic mistrust within multilateral groupings such as the SCO? Critically analyse.
New · District CollectorCan you hold the district for 72 hours?Floods, a heatwave, an outbreak, a grievance queue. Take the decisions, see the consequences.Play →People-centric cultural diplomacy takes soft power beyond governments to people's "hearts and minds". India's First SCO Civilizational Dialogue Forum ("Tehzeeb Ki Guftagu"), held in New Delhi in November 2026, tests this against deep mistrust inside the SCO [1]. Culture can ease that mistrust, but it cannot remove it.
How cultural diplomacy eases mistrust
- Low-friction channel: The SCO decides by consensus, so security talks often stall. The 2025 Qingdao Defence Ministers' Meeting ended with no agreed document [3]. Heritage dialogue still keeps all sides talking.
- Shared narratives: Purana Qila was begun by Humayun and carried forward by Sher Shah Suri. It holds layers of Central Asian and Afghan heritage, and even Pakistan's minister spoke of it [1].
- Beyond the state: Themes such as youth, digitalisation and joint projects build public support that can outlast a diplomatic chill [1].
- Agenda-setting: India proposed the Forum and hosts its first edition [2]. This gives India a leading role in a field China does not dominate. On connectivity, India mainly objects, citing the sovereignty principle in the SCO Charter [5].
Limits of cultural diplomacy
- Hard disputes untouched: Praising a shared monument does not change Pakistan's stance on cross-border terrorism. India's strong anti-terror wording came through the Tianjin Declaration at the summit, not through culture [4].
- Ritual over results: Varanasi's one-year title as SCO Tourism and Cultural Capital (2022–23) brought attention but no lasting mechanism [6]. The Forum's follow-up is still general, with no next host or date named [1].
- "People-centric" in name, state-run in practice: The Ministry of Culture and the ASI organise the Forum [1]. Its reach therefore still depends on political will in each capital.
Cultural diplomacy can therefore offset strategic mistrust only partly. It lowers tensions and builds trust over time, but it complements hard bargaining on terrorism and sovereignty rather than replacing it. A summit decision to make the Forum a regular event, with concrete joint outputs such as a shared digital archive of trade-route heritage, would make it lasting. Guided by the Vedic ideal "Sangachchhadhwam Samvadadhwam" quoted at its inauguration [1], it can help make the SCO a grouping built on dialogue as well as security.
Sources
- 1PIB: Day 2, First SCO Civilizational Dialogue Forum, "Shared cultural heritage a strong bridge connecting SCO nations" (Nov 2026)Forum details, Purana Qila, Pakistan minister's remarks, themes, Ministry of Culture/ASI role, follow-up, Vedic prayer
- 2PIB: Prime Minister participates in the 26th SCO Summit in Bishkek, Kyrgyz RepublicIndia's offer to host the first edition of the Forum
- 3MEA: Rajya Sabha Question No. 567, Exclusion of Pahalgam Terror Attack from SCO DeclarationQingdao meeting ended with no agreed outcome document
- 4PIB: Raksha Mantri at SCO Defence Ministers' Meeting in KyrgyzstanTianjin Declaration's collective stand against terrorism
- 5Charter of the Shanghai Cooperation Organization (MEA)sovereignty and territorial integrity as a core principle
- 6MEA: India–SCO Cooperation briefVaranasi as first SCO Tourism and Cultural Capital (2022–23)