·The Hindu·15 marks·250–350 words

"Indian nationalism during the freedom struggle was largely civic in character." Critically examine, and discuss whether this character has changed in recent decades.

New · District CollectorCan you hold the district for 72 hours?Floods, a heatwave, an outbreak, a grievance queue. Take the decisions, see the consequences.Play →
In this answer
  1. Civic character of the freedom struggle
  2. Limits: why only "largely"
  3. Has the character changed in recent decades?

Civic nationalism bases belonging on shared constitutional values: liberty, equality and fraternity. Ethnic nationalism gives one religion, language or ethnicity a privileged place. The freedom struggle was mostly civic, but never purely so. Today the balance between these two strands is more contested.

Civic character of the freedom struggle

  • Plural coalition: the INC brought together people of different religions, languages, castes and regions. Its early presidents included Dadabhai Naoroji and Badruddin Tyabji.
  • Rights-based vision: the Nehru Report (1928) and the Karachi Resolution (1931) promised fundamental rights and equality whatever a person's religion or caste.
  • Shared symbols, not loyalty tests: "Vande Mataram" became a rallying cry of the 1905 Swadeshi movement. On 24 January 1950 the Constituent Assembly gave it equal status with the National Anthem [1].

Limits: why only "largely"

  • Religious idiom: Tilak's Ganapati and Shivaji festivals, and other revivalist imagery, alienated sections of Muslims.
  • Rival ethnic projects: separate electorates (1909), the Muslim League's two-nation theory and the Hindu Mahasabha pulled the other way. They ended in Partition.
  • Caste blind spot: Ambedkar argued that political nationalism pushed aside social justice for the Depressed Classes.

Has the character changed in recent decades?

  • Signs of an ethnic turn: identity mobilisation since the 1990s (the Ram Janmabhoomi movement), recurring communal tensions, and disputes over language and delimitation show pressure to define the nation through one dominant identity.
  • Civic resilience: Articles 14, 15 and 25–30 still protect the civic core. So does S.R. Bommai (1994), which held secularism to be a basic feature of the Constitution. The linguistic reorganisation of states made room for diversity without breaking up the country.
  • Symbolic nationalism: the 150-year Vande Mataram commemoration reported 39,783+ events across 36 States/UTs and 653 districts [2]. But reach is not the same as inclusion. Such campaigns stay civic only if taking part is voluntary and is not treated as a test of loyalty.

India's nationalism has not been wholly replaced. The balance is contested, though it is still anchored in the civic settlement of 1950. Fraternity can be strengthened through Article 51A(e) (the duty to promote harmony across religious, linguistic and regional lines), inclusive commemorations and constitutional morality. That would keep the Preamble's promise of "the dignity of the individual and the unity and integrity of the Nation."

Sources

  1. 1150 Years of Vande Mataram: A Melody That Became a Movement, PIB backgrounder (6 November 2025)role in the Swadeshi movement; adopted as National Song with equal status to the Anthem (1950)
  2. 2Patriotic fervor at an all-time high! Enthusiastic start to the year-long commemoration of 150 Years of Vande Mataram, PIB39,783+ events, 36 States/UTs, 653 districts (self-reported on the campaign portal)

More from this note