"The legitimacy of the Election Commission depends as much on the process of its decision-making as on its constitutional powers." Discuss in the light of recent controversies over electoral roll revision.
New · District CollectorCan you hold the district for 72 hours?Floods, a heatwave, an outbreak, a grievance queue. Take the decisions, see the consequences.Play →Article 324 gives the Election Commission of India (ECI) "superintendence, direction and control" over electoral rolls and elections. But an umpire's authority rests on being seen to be fair. The dispute over the Special Intensive Revision (SIR) in 2025–26 shows that how the ECI decides now matters as much as what it is allowed to decide.
Constitutional powers: the legal foundation
- Wide power: Article 324, read with the RPA, 1950 (Sec. 21), lets the ECI order a special revision of the rolls. The SIR was first ordered in Bihar on 24 June 2025 [2].
- Judicial endorsement: On 27 May 2026 the Supreme Court upheld the SIR, confirming that the ECI has the power to revise rolls [2].
- Statutory framework: The CEC & ECs Act, 2023 replaced the 1991 Act. It sets up a two-stage Search and Selection Committee process [3].
Why process decides legitimacy
- Collective decision-making: The ECI is a multi-member body. T.N. Seshan v. Union of India (1995) treated the CEC as first among equals. The law requires decisions to be unanimous as far as possible, and by majority otherwise [4].
- Transparency gap: In a November 2026 rejoinder, the Leader of the Opposition said the ECI had produced no minutes, file notings or recorded approvals to back its claim that the SIR was "unanimous" [1].
- Recording dissent: The petitioners' interrogatories ask whether Election Commissioners objected in writing on the SIR, ECINET or Form 6 [1]. When minority views stay hidden, people start to suspect that one member dominates.
- Appointment design: The executive holds a 2:1 majority on the selection panel. PRS has flagged that limiting eligibility to Secretary-rank officers could exclude other suitable candidates [4]. Both points affect whether the ECI is seen as independent.
- Inclusion stakes: Wrongful deletions hurt migrants, the poor and people without documents the most. Fair procedure, meaning notice and a right of appeal, protects the universal adult franchise of Article 326.
Way forward
- Publish minutes and dissent notes for major decisions.
- Set out standard procedures in law for roll revision: notice, hearing, and searchable lists of deleted names.
- Give ECs removal protection equal to the CEC's, and rebalance the selection panel in the spirit of Anoop Baranwal (2023).
Constitutional power gives the ECI its authority, but a fair and recorded process is what earns public trust. A Commission that writes down its deliberations and dissents openly can be held accountable and keeps its independence. That strengthens the "free and fair elections" which the Supreme Court has called part of the basic structure.
Sources
- 1The Hindu: "No proof from ECI to show SIR was a 'unanimous' decision, Rahul Gandhi to SC" (Nov 2026): the rejoinder saying no minutes or file notings were produced; the interrogatories on dissent over SIR, ECINET and Form 6
- 2Supreme Court of India, Judgment dated 27 May 2026 (Diary No. 35785/2025): SIR ordered on 24 June 2025; SIR and the ECI's power to revise rolls upheld
- 3PRS Bill Summary: CEC and Other ECs Bill, 2023: replacement of the 1991 Act; Search and Selection Committees
- 4PRS Legislative Brief: CEC and Other ECs Bill, 2023: unanimity-else-majority rule; concern over Secretary-rank eligibility