·The Hindu·15 marks·250–350 words

In light of the theme of the 81st UNGA, evaluate India's call for 'reformed multilateralism'.

New · District CollectorCan you hold the district for 72 hours?Floods, a heatwave, an outbreak, a grievance queue. Take the decisions, see the consequences.Play →
In this answer
  1. Merits of India's call
  2. Limitations

The 81st UNGA's theme is "Restoring Trust, Managing Transformation: A United Nations That Delivers for All" [1]. It accepts that the UN's legitimacy now depends on results. India calls for 'reformed multilateralism', meaning "empowered, functional, and impact-oriented" institutions anchored in a reformed Security Council [2]. This call speaks directly to the trust deficit, but it also has clear limits.

Merits of India's call

  • Representation builds trust: India wants a UNSC "reflective of contemporary realities", expanded in both permanent and non-permanent categories [2]. That would give the Global South a share in decisions it is expected to carry out.
  • Targets the root of the delivery gap: The Council often cannot act in major conflicts because Article 27(3) requires the "concurring votes" of the permanent members [5]. No efficiency drive touches this problem.
  • Practical process demand: India seeks text-based IGN negotiations with "concrete outcomes in a fixed time-frame" [2]. Working on a written draft would end the open-ended rounds of speeches.
  • Coalition backing: India pursues the demand with the G4 and the L.69 group of developing countries [2]. This gives it wider legitimacy than a single country's bid.

Limitations

  • Reform can be blocked by the P5: Under Article 108, any Charter amendment must be ratified by all permanent members [5]. These are the same states whose privileges reform would dilute.
  • Seen as seat-seeking: India's stated top priority is its own permanent seat [2]. Rivals therefore present the call as a national ambition rather than reform of the whole system.
  • Narrow diagnosis: The UN's delivery crisis is also financial and administrative:
  • $1.586 billion in unpaid dues by December 2025 forced a 15.1% budget cut and the loss of 2,681 posts for 2026 [3];
  • the UN80 Mandate Implementation Review found duplication and a "proliferation of meetings and reports" [4].

Reform focused only on the UNSC fixes neither problem.

India's call for reformed multilateralism therefore fits UNGA-81's trust agenda well. It is necessary but not sufficient: it targets the Council's legitimacy deficit, the deepest source of mistrust, but leaves the fiscal and mandate gaps untouched. India can make its case more credible by paying its dues on time, backing the UN80 mandate review, and pressing for IGN outcomes within a fixed deadline alongside its UNSC advocacy. Only a UN that is both representative and efficient can truly "deliver for all" [1]. Such a UN would also advance SDG 16's goal of inclusive, accountable institutions.

Sources

  1. 181st Session of the UN General Assembly, United Nations: UNGA-81 theme
  2. 2India's Priorities for the 78th Session of the UNGA, Ministry of External Affairs: reformed multilateralism, UNSC expansion, text-based IGN in a fixed time-frame, G4 and L.69, permanent seat as top priority
  3. 3UN chief warns unpaid dues near $1.6 billion, as budget cuts deepen, UN News (Dec 2025): $1.586 billion in arrears, 15.1% budget cut, 2,681 posts cut
  4. 4UN80 Initiative: Frequently Asked Questions, United Nations: Mandate Implementation Review findings (duplication, proliferation of meetings and reports)
  5. 5Charter of the United Nations, Full Text: Article 27(3) concurring votes; Article 108 amendment procedure

More from this note