·The Hindu·15 marks·250–350 words

Minilateral groupings like the G20 and BRICS build trust but cannot replace the legitimacy of multilateral institutions. Discuss in the context of India's push for reformed multilateralism.

New · District CollectorCan you hold the district for 72 hours?Floods, a heatwave, an outbreak, a grievance queue. Take the decisions, see the consequences.Play →
In this answer
  1. How minilaterals build trust
  2. Why they cannot replace multilateral legitimacy
  3. India's push for reformed multilateralism

Minilateral groupings are small, selective clubs such as the G20 and BRICS. They are quick and flexible, and they help build trust among the powers that matter most. Universal bodies like the UN draw their legitimacy from the consent of all 193 member states, and clubs cannot match that. India works through both, so its push for reformed multilateralism is about fixing the universal system, not replacing it.

How minilaterals build trust

  • Faster consensus: small tables avoid the deadlock of bodies where every member must be heard. India's G20 presidency got the African Union admitted as a permanent member at the New Delhi Summit in 2023 [1].
  • Voice for the Global South: BRICS lets developing economies coordinate on finance and trade without the West in the room.
  • Bridging rival blocs: clubs give India a seat alongside both the West and China–Russia, which supports strategic autonomy.

Why they cannot replace multilateral legitimacy

  • Selective membership: decisions taken by a few states lack the universal consent that UN processes carry.
  • No binding authority: under Articles 24–25 of the UN Charter, only the Security Council can make decisions that bind all members on peace and security [2].
  • Depends on great-power interest: a club is useful only while its big members value it. If the major powers deal directly with each other, the real decisions move out of BRICS and the G20.

India's push for reformed multilateralism

  • India's 2021–22 UNSC term was built around NORMS (New Orientation for a Reformed Multilateral System), with Council reform at its centre [3].
  • Structural hurdle: the veto in Article 27 [2] and the rule in Article 108 that all five permanent members must ratify any Charter amendment [4] mean reform needs the consent of the very powers it would dilute.
  • Way forward: use the trust India has built in clubs (G20, Quad, BRICS) to put together coalitions for UN reform, such as the G4 and the African Union. India should also build enough economic and technological weight that keeping it out of the system becomes costly for the permanent members.

Minilaterals and multilateral bodies do different jobs. Clubs build trust, but legitimacy comes from universal bodies. India's best course is to turn its convening record in clubs into momentum for a more representative UN. That serves the vision of Vasudhaiva Kutumbakam and SDG 16's call for inclusive global institutions.

Sources

  1. 1New India Samachar (PIB), 1–15 October 2023African Union made a permanent G20 member at the New Delhi Summit
  2. 2UN Charter, Chapter V: The Security Council (Articles 23–32)the Council's binding authority (Articles 24–25); the permanent members' veto (Article 27)
  3. 3Ministry of External Affairs: India's priorities for its UNSC termthe NORMS agenda with Council reform at its centre
  4. 4UN Charter, Chapter XVIII: Amendments (Articles 108–109)amendments need ratification by two-thirds of members, including all five permanent members

More from this note