Political culture often outlives political power. Comment with reference to recent State-level transitions in India.
In this answer
Political culture — the shared attitudes, habits and informal rules through which power is actually exercised — is embedded in society, whereas political power changes with every verdict. Recent State-level transitions suggest that the ballot replaces rulers far faster than it replaces the culture they leave behind.
Evidence of continuity after a decisive transition
- West Bengal, 2026: the BJP won 207 of 294 seats, ending fifteen years of Trinamool rule [2] — a mandate built on anger against extortion, strongman politics, unemployment and youth out-migration [1].
- Yet roughly a hundred days on, control of rent-yielding local networks — auto and e-rickshaw stands, local syndicates — reportedly passed to new claimants instead of being dismantled [1].
- The personnel changed; the practice of informal, extra-legal local authority survived.
Why culture outlives power
- Defection as a carrier: leaders formed inside the old system carry its methods across. Chief Minister Suvendu Adhikari himself moved from the Trinamool to the BJP in 2020 [1]. The Tenth Schedule penalises switching party membership, not importing political method [3].
- Continuity of incentives: campaign finance, local dispute settlement and welfare access still flow through intermediaries, so new incumbents inherit their usefulness.
- Contested absorption: the reported three-way tension between the RSS, State president Samik Bhattacharya and the Chief Minister is essentially over whether to absorb or refuse these inherited networks [1].
But culture is not immutable
- It shifts when institutions change incentives — the Second ARC's Ethics in Governance report urged decriminalisation of politics, transparency and stronger accountability machinery [4] — and where local self-government functions transparently.
Thus a transition of power is necessary but insufficient; the deeper contest is over political habit. Governments that institutionalise their mandate — through clean local governance, transparent contracting and empowered panchayat and municipal bodies — convert an anti-incumbency verdict into genuine renewal, honouring the Constitution's promise of impartial, accountable governance.
Sources
- 1Sayantan Ghosh, "The battle within the BJP in Bengal", The Hindu, 1 September 2026intra-party contest, patronage networks changing hands, campaign themes, Adhikari's 2020 defection
- 2Election Commission of India, Party-wise Result, West Bengal Assembly Election 2026BJP 207 of 294 seats
- 3The Constitution of India (Tenth Schedule), India Codedisqualification on ground of defection
- 4Second Administrative Reforms Commission, Fourth Report: Ethics in Governancerecommendations on decriminalising politics and accountability