·The Hindu·15 marks·250–350 words

"Prohibition is morally appealing yet administratively futile." Discuss with reference to lotteries and gambling regulation in India.

New · District CollectorCan you hold the district for 72 hours?Floods, a heatwave, an outbreak, a grievance queue. Take the decisions, see the consequences.Play →
In this answer
  1. Why prohibition is morally appealing
  2. Why it proves administratively futile

Gambling is one of the few "vices" Indian law chooses to regulate rather than extinguish: the Lotteries (Regulation) Act, 1998 permits State Governments to organise lotteries subject to statutory conditions [1]. Prohibition satisfies moral intuition, but because demand survives the ban, its administrative record is weak.

Why prohibition is morally appealing

  • Constitutional morality: the Supreme Court has held gambling to be res extra commercium — not trade or commerce entitled to the ordinary protections of commercial activity [3].
  • Regressive harm: lottery spending absorbs a far larger share of a poor household's income, so "revenue" is largely collected from those least able to bear it.
  • Conflict of interest: under the 1998 Act the State is itself the organiser [1], while Kerala's lottery revenue touched ₹9,972.97 crore in 2019-20 [4] — the seller is also the referee.
  • Parliament accepted this logic in the Promotion and Regulation of Online Gaming Act, 2025, which prohibits all online money games, of chance or skill [5].

Why it proves administratively futile

  • Demand outlives supply: US Prohibition (1920–33) left drinking intact, transferred supply to criminal syndicates and forfeited excise revenue.
  • Bans only relocate the ticket: Section 5 lets a State bar sale of other States' tickets, but cannot stop those States printing and selling them — supply stays legal at source [1].
  • Capacity deficit: offshore platforms, mirror domains and informal payment channels make online enforcement reactive, which is why the 2025 Act needed a dedicated Authority and blocking powers, operationalised through the Rules, 2026 [5][6].
  • Fiscal self-defeat: a ban surrenders the States' taxing power over betting and gambling under Entry 62, List II [3], handing the margin to untaxed operators.

The choice, therefore, is not between morality and revenue but between visible, auditable supply and invisible, criminal supply. The way forward is accountable regulation: separating the regulator from the organising department, mandating published draw audits under the Lotteries (Regulation) Rules, 2010 [2], capping advertising and draw frequency, and using registration-and-blocking tools against unlicensed platforms [5]. Regulation that is transparent protects the vulnerable more effectively than a prohibition that exists only on paper.

Sources

  1. 1The Lotteries (Regulation) Act, 1998 (India Code)_act,_1998.pdf) — State Governments as organisers; Section 4 conditions; Section 5 power to ban other States' tickets
  2. 2Lotteries (Regulation) Rules, 2010subordinate rule-making space for audit and disclosure norms
  3. 3Supreme Court, judgment dated 11 February 2025 (2025 INSC 181)gambling as res extra commercium; lotteries taxable by States under Entry 62, List II, not by the Centre
  4. 4Directorate of Kerala State Lotteries — Revenue Collection₹9,972.97 crore revenue in 2019-20
  5. 5PIB — Government Enacts Online Gaming Act, 2025prohibition of all online money games; Online Gaming Authority; blocking and penalty provisions
  6. 6PIB — Promotion and Regulation of Online Gaming Rules, 2026operational rules under the 2025 Act

More from this note