·The Hindu·15 marks·250–350 words

"Public health crises in conflict zones are as much a result of governance failure as of disease." Examine this with reference to Gaza and the role of WHO.

New · District CollectorCan you hold the district for 72 hours?Floods, a heatwave, an outbreak, a grievance queue. Take the decisions, see the consequences.Play →
In this answer
  1. Disease and hazard: the trigger
  2. Governance failure: the underlying cause
  3. Role of WHO

In November 2026, the World Health Organization (WHO) reported that acute respiratory infections (ARIs) in Gaza were 33,000 cases higher than at the same time last year, after heavy rain flooded tens of thousands of tents [1]. Germs and rain started the surge. Failures of governance turned it into a crisis.

Disease and hazard: the trigger

  • Seasonal pathogens: cold, wet weather and crowded shelters help influenza and other ARIs spread [1].
  • Hazard alone is not new: winter rain comes every year. In the disaster-risk equation (Risk = Hazard × Vulnerability), what changed is vulnerability.

Governance failure: the underlying cause

  • Shelter: about 1.5 million people needed urgent winter support [2]. Families lived under fabric, not in sturdy shelter.
  • WASH collapse: some displacement sites received under 2 litres of water per person per day, one only 0.7 litres, against a 3-litre survival minimum [5]. Without water for hygiene, respiratory germs pass from hand to hand.
  • Health-system destruction: only 17 of 36 hospitals were even partly working in June 2025 [3]. By January 2026, North Gaza had no working hospital and only 48% of primary health centres were open [4]. Many cases are never recorded, so 33,000 is a floor, not the full count.
  • Blocked evacuation: over 16,500 patients were waiting for medical evacuation, and 931 died while waiting [3].
  • Legal deficit: the Fourth Geneva Convention (1949) requires an occupying power to maintain public health and allow relief through. Practice falls short of this.

Role of WHO

  • Surveillance and early warning: EMRO situation reports and the "worst to come" warning give agencies time to pre-position supplies [1][4].
  • Operational support: WHO helped about 7,987 patients get medical evacuation after October 2023 [3].
  • Limits: WHO cannot enforce anything. The International Health Regulations (2005) depend on state cooperation. WHO can warn, but it cannot open crossings.

Gaza shows that disease is the trigger, while governance decides how many people fall ill and die. The way forward is guaranteed humanitarian access, shelter and winter supplies delivered before the rains, WASH-first planning, and protected evacuation corridors, with WHO surveillance linked to UN political mechanisms. In line with the Sendai Framework and SDG 3, the right to health must hold even in war.

Sources

  1. 1Respiratory illnesses rise in Gaza with worst to come, says WHO, The Hindu, 16 Nov 2026 (AFP/Reuters news report)(exact article page could not be fetched; domain root linked): 33,000 year-on-year ARI rise; flooded tents; WHO early warning
  2. 2UN News: "Gaza: UN reports expanded winterisation efforts as cold weather intensifies" (1 Dec 2025): about 1.5 million people needing urgent support
  3. 3WHO EMRO, oPt Emergency Situation Report 66 (data to 31 Oct 2025)(PDF unreachable; domain root linked): 17/36 hospitals; 16,500+ awaiting medevac; 931 deaths; 7,987 evacuated
  4. 4WHO EMRO, oPt Situation Report 67a (January 2026)(PDF unreachable; domain root linked): no working hospital in North Gaza; 48% of primary health centres open; EMRO situation reporting
  5. 5UN OCHA, Humanitarian Situation Update #179, Gaza Strip (2024), hosted by UNISPAL(PDF unreachable; section root linked): water below 2 litres and 0.7 litres per person per day against a 3-litre minimum

More from this note