"Purifying electoral rolls must not come at the cost of universal adult franchise." Critically examine with reference to the Special Intensive Revision and the remedies that followed.
New · District CollectorCan you hold the district for 72 hours?Floods, a heatwave, an outbreak, a grievance queue. Take the decisions, see the consequences.Play →In this answer
Article 326 guarantees universal adult franchise, and Article 324 makes the ECI responsible for preparing accurate rolls. The Supreme Court upheld the Special Intensive Revision (SIR) under Section 21(3), RP Act, 1950 [4]. Purification is therefore legitimate, but only if inclusion comes first.
Case for purification
- Clean rolls protect the vote: Dead, shifted, duplicate and untraceable entries make impersonation easier. Deletions are limited to these four categories [1].
- Due process built in: BLOs verify house to house [2]. They make two to three visits before marking an elector absent, and voters get prior intimation [1].
- Judicial validation: The Court held the SIR lawful and said it does not itself decide citizenship [4].
Cost to universal franchise
- Scale of exclusion: In Bihar, about 65 lakh names were dropped from the draft roll. The electorate fell from 7.89 crore to 7.42 crore [3]. Clean-up alone hardly explains this, since new voters turn 18 every year.
- Burden on the citizen: The 'untraceable' category hits migrants, daily-wage and shift workers hardest, because they are often away when BLOs visit.
- Costly redress: Appeals go from the ERO to the District Magistrate to the CEO [2]. This helps only those who know they were deleted. Few appeals may reflect how hard it is to claim, not how accurate the roll is.
- Documentary barrier: Even a limited citizenship inquiry [4] puts the burden of proof on poor and less-documented electors.
Remedies that followed: adequate?
- Positives:
- A corrective Special Summary Revision re-enrolled lakhs of eligible names without asking for proof of citizenship.
- A special drive directs BLOs to compare current and pre-SIR rolls to find left-out and young electors [6].
-
Notice before any deletion other than of the dead, and personal ERO checks where deletions exceed 2% of a polling station [5].
-
Gaps:
- Remedies still depend on the voter filing a claim.
- Restoration routes mostly cover States where the SIR is still under way.
- The safeguards came after the mass deletions.
The SIR improved roll integrity, but the remedies only partly repair its cost to inclusion. The way forward:
- Officials should re-check every deletion other than of the dead, using the pre-SIR comparison, without waiting for claims.
- Deleted electors in every State should be restored with their old EPIC number.
- Notice-before-deletion and the 2% check should be written into the Registration of Electors Rules, 1960.
A roll that is clean but incomplete fails Article 326 and SDG 16.7's promise of inclusive participation.
Sources
- 1PIB: ECI's Special Intensive Revision of Electoral Rolls Being Conducted in Phases with Multiple Safeguards to Protect Eligible Voters (2026)deletion categories, repeated visits, prior intimation
- 2PIB: ECI to begin Special Intensive Revision of Electoral Rolls in Bihar (2025)BLO house-to-house verification; appeal from ERO to DM to CEO under Section 24, RP Act
- 3PIB: Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of Electoral Rolls in Bihar Successfully Completed7.89 crore to 7.42 crore; 65 lakh removed from the draft roll
- 4Supreme Court of India, Association for Democratic Reforms v. Election Commission of India, 2026 INSC 564SIR upheld under Section 21(3), RP Act read with Article 324; limited citizenship inquiry
- 5ECI: Note explaining process of annual revision/updation of electoral rolls (FAQ)notice before deletions other than deaths; ERO personal verification where deletions exceed 2%
- 6ECI letter on special drive in States (1 Oct 2026)BLOs to compare current and pre-SIR rolls for left-out and young electors