Why have space agencies relied on military test pilots as their first astronauts? Examine whether India should widen its astronaut pool in future missions.
New · District CollectorCan you hold the district for 72 hours?Floods, a heatwave, an outbreak, a grievance queue. Take the decisions, see the consequences.Play →Gaganyaan is India's first crewed mission. It drew all four of its astronaut candidates from the IAF test-pilot pool: Shubhanshu Shukla, Prashanth Balakrishnan Nair, Ajit Krishnan and Angad Prathap [1]. This follows global practice. Test pilots are the right choice for a first flight, but as the programme matures it will need a wider pool.
Why Test Pilots Fly First
- Experimental-flight skill: test pilots fly new, modified or experimental aircraft and judge how they perform. That is exactly the job on a crew module that has not yet been proven [1].
- Engineering feedback: they work closely with aerospace engineers and help find design flaws [1].
- Calm in a crisis: they are trained to decide fast during high acceleration or sudden cabin depressurisation [1].
- Global precedent: space agencies have historically sent military test pilots as their first astronauts [1].
Should India Widen the Pool?
Case for widening
- Mission specialists: once a launch system has been proven in test flights, agencies add scientists, doctors and engineers. Civilians can also fly after training [1].
- Space station needs: the Bharatiya Antariksh Station (BAS-01, targeted for 2028) will need long-stay crews who run experiments, not only pilots [2].
- Bioastronautics: the study of the medical and behavioural side of living in space gains from having doctors and scientists in orbit [1].
- Equity: a pool limited to pilots leaves out most women and civilians.
Case for caution
- Safety first: the revised programme, funded at ₹20,193 crore, added an extra uncrewed mission. This shows a deliberate choice to lower risk before the first crewed flight [2].
- Time and cost: preparing a crew takes years, as the Gaganyatri training for the joint ISRO–NASA ISS mission shows [3]. Every new batch adds cost.
Way Forward
- Publish selection criteria for mission specialists, since no universal criteria exist [1].
- Start civilian selection now, so BAS crews are ready when the station is [2].
- Use foreign flight seats, as in the ISRO–NASA mission [3], to fly specialists early.
Test pilots are the right people to prove a new vehicle, and scientists and civilians are the right people to use it once it is proven. Widening the pool in clear, published phases (pilots now, specialists for BAS) would turn Gaganyaan from a one-time feat into a lasting, inclusive human-spaceflight programme. That fits the spirit of Article 51A(h), which asks citizens to develop scientific temper.
Sources
- 1How did ISRO pick astronaut candidates for the Gaganyaan mission? — The Hindu (explainer, 19 Nov 2026)IAF test-pilot pool, candidate names, test-pilot roles, mission-specialist practice, bioastronautics, no universal criteria
- 2Cabinet approves Bharatiya Antariksh Station and revised Gaganyaan programme — PIB, Department of Space (18 Sep 2024)₹20,193 crore funding, extra uncrewed mission, BAS-01 target of 2028
- 3Culmination of Initial Phase of Training for Gaganyatris for Joint ISRO-NASA Mission to International Space Station — ISROGaganyatri training for the joint ISRO–NASA ISS mission