·The Hindu·15 marks·250–350 words

Unilateral targeted sanctions are increasingly used to enforce international law where multilateral mechanisms fail. Examine with reference to recent Western measures against West Bank settlement activity.

New · District CollectorCan you hold the district for 72 hours?Floods, a heatwave, an outbreak, a grievance queue. Take the decisions, see the consequences.Play →
In this answer
  1. Why multilateral mechanisms have failed
  2. How unilateral sanctions try to enforce the law
  3. Limitations
  4. Way forward

Unilateral targeted sanctions are restrictions, such as cutting off finance, that one state imposes on named entities without a UN Security Council (UNSC) Chapter VII mandate. In November 2026 the UK sanctioned Israeli construction and property firms building West Bank settlements [1]. The case shows such tools filling an enforcement gap, but their reach is limited.

Why multilateral mechanisms have failed

  • Law without enforcement: UNSC Resolution 2334 (2016) said settlements have no legal validity and are a "flagrant violation" of international law [2]. Settlement building has continued anyway.
  • Veto politics: Resolution 2334 passed only because the US abstained [2]. Council-mandated sanctions are therefore unrealistic.
  • Demands ignored: A UN Palestinian Rights Committee body demanded a halt after over 3,400 E1 units were approved [3]. Israel then sought bids for 1,200 E1 homes [1]. Fourteen mostly Western states asked Israel to reverse 19 new settlements, without effect [4].

How unilateral sanctions try to enforce the law

  • Cutting off finance: The UK aims to remove targets' "access to the finance" that pays for construction [1].
  • Deterrence: The UK has warned firms considering the "unconscionable E1 project" [1], to make bidders back out before they sign.
  • Legal basis: The ICJ Advisory Opinion (2024) said all states must not give aid or assistance to Israel's unlawful presence [5]. The UK is acting on an existing duty, not creating a new rule.
  • Calibrated pressure: Targeting companies, not the state, protects the UK's ties with a "longtime ally" [1].

Limitations

  • Legitimacy: India rejects sanctions not imposed by the UN [6]. BRICS condemned "unilateral coercive measures" [7]. Critics fear powerful states will apply sanctions selectively.
  • Limited bite: Firms that borrow only in Israel lose little, and sanctioned contractors can be replaced. The Israeli Security Cabinet, which decides on settlements [4], is not targeted.
  • Unproven effect: The UK itself calls this only a "first concrete step" [1].

Way forward

  • Coordinate sanctions among like-minded states so that sanctioned firms cannot be easily replaced.
  • Apply the ICJ's non-recognition duty through debates at the UN General Assembly (UNGA) [5]. This route fits India's support for a negotiated two-state solution [8].

Unilateral targeted sanctions thus fill an enforcement gap: the law behind them is multilateral, but the decision to enforce it is national. They gain legitimacy when grounded in UNSC resolutions and ICJ findings and coordinated widely. A UN-centred path to the two-state solution set out in Resolution 2334 remains the lasting answer, with sanctions as a bridge, not a substitute.

Sources

  1. 1U.K. sanctions Israeli companies building West Bank settlements — The Hindu (AP news), 17 Nov 2026UK sanctions on construction and property firms; finance denial; E1 warning; 1,200-home tender; "longtime ally"; "first concrete step"
  2. 2UNSC Resolution 2334 (23 December 2016) — UNISPALsettlements have no legal validity and are a flagrant violation; 14–0 vote with US abstention
  3. 3UN Palestinian Rights Committee Bureau denounces the E1 settlement plan (Aug 2025) — UNISPALover 3,400 E1 units approved; demand for an immediate halt
  4. 4Joint statement of 14 countries condemning the Israeli Security Cabinet's approval of 19 new settlements (24 Dec 2025) — UNISPAL19 settlements approved by the Security Cabinet; call to reverse
  5. 5Summary of the ICJ Advisory Opinion on the Occupied Palestinian Territory (19 July 2024) — UNISPALduties of all states not to aid or assist and not to recognise
  6. 6MEA Distinguished Lectures: India's position on unilateral sanctions — Ministry of External AffairsIndia does not support sanctions that the UN has not imposed
  7. 7Chair's Statement and Outcome Document, BRICS Foreign Ministers' Meeting (15 May 2026) — MEAcondemnation of unilateral coercive measures
  8. 8Lok Sabha Question No. 81: Stand on Palestine Issue — MEAIndia's support for a negotiated two-state solution

More from this note