·The Hindu

No mandate only women personnel can ‘handle’ women in crowd-control operations, Delhi Police to SC

FlashcardsQuick reviseKey facts. One by one.Start →
In this note
  1. At a Glance
  2. Why in the News
  3. Background & Evolution
  4. Core Static Facts
  5. Multi-Dimensional Analysis
  6. Recent Developments (last 12–18 months)
  7. Prelims Hooks
  8. Mains Relevance
  9. Related Topics to Study Next
  10. NCERT Concepts to Revise
  11. Common Errors / Trap Areas

1. At a Glance

  • Core issue: In an affidavit to the Supreme Court, the Delhi Police said that no law requires only women police to "handle" women during crowd-control operations. In its view, the women-only rule in the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita (BNSS), 2023 covers only arrests and searches [1].
  • Context: The affidavit answers allegations that male police officers manhandled women protestors and journalists during protests demanding the resignation of Chief Election Commissioner (CEC) Gyanesh Kumar [1].
  • Second claim: The police also said it was "yet to be determined" whether "reel-makers" can be treated as journalists [1]. This raises the question of who counts as press when protection is extended to journalists [2].
  • UPSC relevance: The case links Art. 19(1)(a)/(b) (speech, press, peaceful assembly), Art. 21 (dignity), gender-sensitive policing, BNSS safeguards for women, and police accountability. These are core GS-II topics, with GS-IV angles.

2. Why in the News

  • 3 October 2026: Three women journalists complained of sexual harassment by Delhi Police personnel while covering protests at Jantar Mantar. The complaints were transferred to the Crime Branch [3].
  • One journalist said she was assaulted by an ACP-rank officer after she asked why no women police personnel were present at the protest site [3]. This is the factual basis for the "only women personnel" dispute.
  • 11 October 2026: The SC directed that lawyers, journalists and other professionals must not be obstructed from doing their work [2].
  • 13 October 2026 (Tuesday): The SC asked for a senior Delhi Police officer to appear in person and explain the allegations [2][4].
  • 18 November 2026: The Delhi Police's affidavit was reported. It denies that any women-only mandate applies to crowd control [1].

3. Background & Evolution

  • The protests: Protests across the country demanded the removal of CEC Gyanesh Kumar. They were tied to opposition to the electoral rolls SIR (Special Intensive Revision), with protests reported from Delhi (Jantar Mantar) and Hyderabad [1].
  • Petitioners before the SC:
  • Network of Women in Media, India (NWMI), represented by advocate Aarthi Rajan [1]
  • Delhi Union of Journalists [1]
  • Free Speech Collective [1]
  • Kerala Union of Working Journalists [1]

  • What the petitioners want: NWMI asked for binding safeguards for women journalists covering protests [4].

  • Legal background: The CrPC, 1973 protected women during arrest. Section 46(4) CrPC, the bar on arresting women at night, is now Section 43(5) BNSS [5].
  • Chronology: 1. Jantar Mantar protest and complaints (3 Oct 2026) [3] 2. SC order against obstructing journalists (11 Oct) [2] 3. SC summons a senior officer (13 Oct) [2] 4. Delhi Police counter-affidavit (reported 18 Nov 2026) [1][2]

4. Core Static Facts

Item Fact
Statute referred to by police Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 [1]
Police position Women-only handling is "not a statutory mandate in the context of crowd-control operations". It applies only to "searches and arrests" [1]
Sec. 43(1) BNSS When arresting a woman, police shall not touch her unless the officer is a female or circumstances otherwise require. If she is told orally, her submission to custody is presumed [5]
Sec. 43(5) BNSS No arrest of a woman between sunset and sunrise, except in exceptional circumstances. Even then, a woman police officer must first get written permission from a Judicial Magistrate First Class [5]
Judicial reading of 43(5) The Madras HC held that Sec. 46(4) CrPC / 43(5) BNSS is directory, so breaking it does not by itself make an arrest illegal [5]
Medical examination of women Must be done by, or under the supervision of, a female registered medical practitioner. Secondary sources give different section numbers (51 or 53 BNSS), so check India Code [5]
Who signed the affidavit Joint Commissioner of Police (Surender Kumar) [2]
Controlling authority of Delhi Police Ministry of Home Affairs, because Delhi is a UT with an Assembly and "police" is excluded from the Delhi Assembly's powers under Art. 239AA (static fact; not from the retrieved sources)
Investigating unit for the complaints Delhi Police Crime Branch [3]

5. Multi-Dimensional Analysis

Legal / Constitutional

  • The police read the women-only safeguard narrowly: BNSS mentions it only for arrests and searches [1]. The petitioners argue that the purpose of the safeguard (dignity and bodily integrity) applies wherever police physically touch a woman.
  • Art. 19(1)(b) protects the right to assemble peaceably and without arms, subject to Art. 19(3) restrictions. Art. 19(1)(a) covers press freedom. The SC's 11 Oct order protects professionals working at protest sites [2].
  • Art. 21 (dignity) and Art. 15(3) (special provisions for women) support reading the safeguards purposively, not literally.

Social / Gender

  • The complaints of sexual harassment came after a journalist asked why no women police were at the site [3]. This shows a deployment gap, not just a legal gap.
  • Women journalists face two risks at protests: harm to their work (obstruction) and harm to their person (harassment). NWMI's demand for binding safeguards addresses both [4].

Ethical / Governance

  • Accountability: Complaints against police are being investigated by the same force's Crime Branch [3]. This raises the question of independent oversight, such as Police Complaints Authorities (Prakash Singh, 2006).
  • Proportionality: Saying "there is no mandate" is not the same as saying the conduct was appropriate. Ethically, the State is expected to follow the purpose of a rule, not just the minimum it literally requires.

Media / Free Speech

  • The police said the SC's protection for journalists was not meant for "so-called reel makers and social media influencers" [2]. The question of who counts as a journalist in the digital age is still open [1].
  • The police also said that anyone removed by mistaken identity was released once their credentials were verified [2].

Administrative

  • Delhi Police reports to the MHA, so the issue has a Union-level dimension.
  • Women's share in India's police forces is low, which makes it hard to deploy women personnel for every crowd-control task. The police's legal argument partly reflects this capacity shortage.

6. Recent Developments (last 12–18 months)

  • 3 Oct 2026: Three women journalists file complaints, which are transferred to the Crime Branch [3].
  • 11 Oct 2026: SC directs that journalists, lawyers and other professionals must not be obstructed [2].
  • 13 Oct 2026: SC asks a senior Delhi Police officer to appear in person [2][4].
  • Oct 2026: SC asks the Centre to respond on guidelines for how police interact with the media [6].
  • 18 Nov 2026: Delhi Police affidavit says there is no women-only mandate for crowd control and questions whether reel-makers are journalists [1][2].

7. Prelims Hooks

  • BNSS, 2023 replaced the CrPC, 1973 (in force since 1 July 2024; static fact).
  • Under Sec. 43(1) BNSS, a woman being arrested may be touched only by a female officer, unless circumstances otherwise require [5].
  • Sec. 43(5) BNSS bars arresting women between sunset and sunrise, except in exceptional cases [5].
  • A night arrest of a woman needs prior written permission from a Judicial Magistrate First Class, obtained by a woman police officer [5].
  • Sec. 43(5) BNSS corresponds to Sec. 46(4) CrPC [5].
  • The Madras HC held the night-arrest bar to be directory, not mandatory [5].
  • NWMI = Network of Women in Media, India [1].
  • KUWJ = Kerala Union of Working Journalists, one of the petitioners [1].
  • The protests sought the removal of CEC Gyanesh Kumar [1].
  • Jantar Mantar in New Delhi is the designated protest site where the alleged incidents happened [3].
  • Art. 19(1)(b): the right to assemble peaceably and without arms (static fact).
  • Delhi Police is controlled by the MHA, not the Delhi Government (static fact).

8. Mains Relevance

  • GS-II:
  • Fundamental Rights (Art. 19, 21)
  • Role of the judiciary
  • Protection of vulnerable sections (women)
  • Statutory reforms in criminal procedure

  • GS-I: Women's issues; social empowerment.

  • GS-III: Internal security, including police reforms and crowd management.
  • GS-IV: Ethics in public administration, accountability, and following the spirit versus the letter of the law.
  • Question stems: 1. "Gender-sensitive policing cannot be confined to the letter of procedural law." Examine this in the context of BNSS safeguards for women and crowd-control operations. (15 marks) 2. With the rise of digital content creators, who should qualify as a "journalist" for legal protection? Discuss the implications for press freedom under Article 19(1)(a). (10 marks) 3. Critically evaluate the mechanisms for police accountability in India, with reference to recent allegations of excesses during protests. (15 marks)

9. Related Topics to Study Next

  • BNSS / BNS / BSA, 2023: the full set of criminal law reforms and how they map to the old CrPC sections.
  • Prakash Singh v. UoI (2006): police reform directions, including Police Complaints Authorities.
  • Mazdoor Kisan Shakti Sangathan v. UoI (2018) and the Shaheen Bagh case (Amit Sahni, 2020): how courts balance the right to protest at Jantar Mantar and in public spaces.
  • Women in police: representation figures (BPR&D data) and reservation targets.
  • Art. 239AA and the Delhi governance model: why police stays with the Union.
  • Appointment and removal of the CEC: the CEC & ECs Act, 2023, and the SIR controversy.
  • Press freedom: Art. 19(1)(a), the Press Council of India, and the regulation of digital media and influencers.
  • D.K. Basu v. State of WB (1997): guidelines on arrest and custodial safeguards.

10. NCERT Concepts to Revise

  • Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita 2023 (Polity): The women-only safeguard on arrests and searches sits in this law, and the police read it narrowly.
  • Right to protest (Polity): The dispute arises from policing of protests at Jantar Mantar, where Article 19(1)(a) and (b) rights apply.
  • Freedom of speech and expression (Polity): Press freedom of journalists covering protests, and who counts as a journalist, falls under this right.
  • Fundamental rights (Polity): Articles 19 and 21 on speech, assembly and dignity form the constitutional basis of the petitioners' case.
  • Police (Polity): The case is about how police conduct crowd control and deploy women personnel.
  • Accountability (Polity): Complaints against police are probed by the same force, raising questions of independent oversight.
  • Judicial magistrate (Polity): Night arrest of a woman needs prior written permission from a Judicial Magistrate First Class.
  • Executive magistrate (Polity): Helps avoid the exam trap of confusing it with the Judicial Magistrate who gives night-arrest permission.
  • Ministry of Home Affairs (Polity): Delhi Police reports to the MHA, giving the issue a Union-level dimension.
  • Union territory (Polity): Delhi's status as a UT explains why police is not under the Delhi Government.
  • Judiciary (Polity): The Supreme Court is shielding journalists and summoning a senior police officer to explain the allegations.
  • Amit Sahni v. Commissioner of Police (Polity): Key precedent on balancing the right to protest with public order, useful for questions on protest policing.
  • Press Council of India (Polity): Statutory body for press freedom and standards, relevant to defining who counts as press.
  • Bureau of Police Research and Development (Polity): It publishes data on women's share in police forces, which bears on the deployment gap.

11. Common Errors / Trap Areas

  • Night-arrest permission: It is a Judicial Magistrate First Class, not an Executive Magistrate. The permission must be written and obtained beforehand, not afterwards.
  • Section numbering: Do not confuse CrPC 46(4) with BNSS 43(5). Secondary sources disagree on the BNSS section for the female medical examination rule, so check India Code.
  • Scope of the women-only rule: In the statute it applies expressly to arrest and search. The legal dispute is precisely whether it extends to crowd control [1].
  • Directory vs mandatory: The Madras HC held the night-arrest bar directory [5]. Do not write that breaking it automatically voids an arrest.
  • Control of Delhi Police: It is the MHA, not the Delhi Government or the LG acting independently.

Sources

  1. 1No mandate only women personnel can 'handle' women in crowd-control operations, Delhi Police to SC — The Hinduthehindu.com · tier 4
  2. 2Reel Makers Not Entitled To Journalistic Protection During Protests, Delhi Police To Supreme Court — LiveLawlivelaw.in
  3. 33 women journalists allege sexual harassment by police during Jantar Mantar protest; Crime Branch to probe — Onmanoramaonmanorama.com
  4. 4Supreme Court seeks senior Delhi Police officers' presence over alleged assault on women journalists; NWMI seeks binding safeguards — SabrangIndiasabrangindia.in
  5. 5Madras HC on Night Arrests of Women: BNSS & CrPC Provisions Explained — Vajiram & Ravi — Women's Arrest at Night — PW Only IASvajiramandravi.com
  6. 6SC Seeks Centre's Response on Guidelines for Police Interactions With Media — Deccan Chronicledeccanchronicle.com

NCERT concepts in this note

Also on 19 November

All 19 November articles →