Former CEC calls for disclosure of SIR decision records
FlashcardsQuick reviseKey facts. One by one.Start →In this note
1. At a Glance
- Topic: Former Chief Election Commissioner S.Y. Quraishi has called for an independent audit of the Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of electoral rolls. He also wants the decision records and digital audit trails made public, and names deleted without lawful authority restored [1].
- Core issue: Large-scale voter deletions in West Bengal. Most appeals were not heard before the Assembly election, so most of the people who appealed could not vote [1].
- Why it matters for UPSC: The topic connects Art. 324 (the ECI's power over elections), Art. 326 (universal adult franchise), the RPA 1950 (the law on electoral rolls), and debates on how independent and credible constitutional bodies are [1][3].
- Mains themes: transparency in administrative decisions, due process before someone loses the vote, and judicial oversight of the ECI [1].
2. Why in the News
- 20 Nov 2026 (Friday): Quraishi gave the 17th V.M. Tarkunde Memorial Lecture in Delhi. The theme was "Constitutional Institutions of India: Where Are They Headed?" [1]
- He said the ECI's credibility "may take years, perhaps decades, to repair" [1].
- He cited West Bengal figures: 27 lakh voters were deleted during adjudication, 22 lakh appealed, and only 1,607 names were restored before the Assembly election because hearings had not been held [1].
- He said later appellate tribunal decisions reportedly found 93% of more than 1.2 lakh exclusions they examined to be incorrect [1].
3. Background & Evolution
- Legal basis: Electoral rolls are prepared and revised under the Representation of the People Act, 1950. Section 21(3) lets the ECI order a special revision at any time, for reasons it records. The ECI's overall power comes from Art. 324 [3].
- Intensive revision vs summary revision: An intensive revision rebuilds the roll largely from scratch, with house-to-house verification by Booth Level Officers (BLOs). A summary revision only updates the existing roll [3].
- Milestones:
- 24 Jun 2025: The ECI ordered the SIR in Bihar. This order was challenged in the Supreme Court, and the Court delivered a judgment in that matter on 27 May 2026 (Case No. 35785/2025) [2].
- 2025–26: The SIR was extended in phases to other States and UTs, including West Bengal, where the Assembly election followed [1].
-
2026: Appellate tribunals heard appeals from people excluded in West Bengal [1].
-
Earlier credibility concerns he cited: strain on the ECI "since 2019", Election Commissioner Ashok Lavasa's dissent, and the controversy over 2024 Lok Sabha turnout figures [1].
4. Core Static Facts
| Item | Fact |
|---|---|
| Constitutional body | Election Commission of India: Art. 324 [3] |
| Right to be on the roll | Art. 326, adult suffrage at 18 years (61st Amendment, 1988) [3] |
| Law on electoral rolls | RPA 1950 (rolls); RPA 1951 (conduct of elections) [3] |
| Special revision power | Sec. 21(3), RPA 1950 [3] |
| Procedural rules | Registration of Electors Rules, 1960 [3] |
| Field officials | Electoral Registration Officer (ERO), who decides; BLO, who verifies house to house [3] |
| Appeal route (normal law) | Sec. 24, RPA 1950: ERO → District Election Officer → Chief Electoral Officer [3] |
| Appointment law | CEC and Other ECs (Appointment, Conditions of Service and Term of Office) Act, 2023 [3] |
| West Bengal deletions (per Quraishi) | 27 lakh deleted; 22 lakh appealed; 1,607 restored before the poll [1] |
| Tribunal findings (per Quraishi) | 93% of more than 1.2 lakh exclusions found incorrect [1] |
| Lecture | 17th V.M. Tarkunde Memorial Lecture, Delhi [1] |
5. Multi-Dimensional Analysis
Legal / Constitutional
- Wrongly deleting a name takes away the Art. 326 franchise. Quraishi says the deletions lacked "lawful authority", so restoration should be automatic [1].
- He argued the Supreme Court could have let the roughly 2.7 million pending appellants vote, given how large the number was [1].
- The question is whether the Art. 324 "plenary" power can be used in ways that bypass the procedural safeguards in RPA 1950 [1][3].
Ethical / Governance
- He wants decision records and digital audit trails disclosed. The aim is to make each deletion traceable and open to review [1].
- An independent audit would be an outside check on a body that otherwise checks itself [1].
- He argues that institutional credibility is slow to rebuild once it is lost [1].
Social
- When 22 lakh people appeal and only 1,607 are restored, the burden of due process lands on the voter. Migrants, the poor and people without documents are hit hardest [1].
- A 93% error rate among decided exclusions suggests the deletions were made too hastily [1].
Administrative
- Hearing backlog: the appeal process could not keep pace with how fast deletions were made [1].
- Timing: the revision ran close to an election, so there was little time to correct mistakes [1].
Historical
- He traces the strain to 2019, through the Lavasa dissent and the 2024 turnout data row [1].
6. Recent Developments (last 12–18 months)
- 24 Jun 2025: ECI ordered the SIR in Bihar [2].
- 27 May 2026: Supreme Court delivered its judgment in the challenge to the Bihar SIR order (Case No. 35785/2025) [2].
- 2026 (before the WB Assembly poll): 27 lakh deletions in West Bengal; 22 lakh appeals; 1,607 restorations before the vote [1].
- After the poll, 2026: appellate tribunals reportedly found 93% of more than 1.2 lakh exclusions incorrect [1].
- 20 Nov 2026: Quraishi called for an audit, disclosure of records and restoration of names [1].
7. Prelims Hooks
- The ECI's superintendence, direction and control of electoral rolls comes from Art. 324 [3].
- Art. 326 sets adult suffrage, with 18 years as the qualifying age [3].
- The voting age was cut from 21 to 18 by the 61st Constitutional Amendment Act, 1988 [3].
- Electoral rolls are governed by RPA 1950, not RPA 1951 [3].
- The power to order a special revision is in Sec. 21(3), RPA 1950 [3].
- Roll procedure is set out in the Registration of Electors Rules, 1960 [3].
- BLOs do the house-to-house verification during an intensive revision [3].
- The SIR began in Bihar by ECI order dated 24 June 2025 [2].
- The Supreme Court judgment on the Bihar SIR challenge is dated 27 May 2026 [2].
- S.Y. Quraishi is a former CEC. He gave the 17th V.M. Tarkunde Memorial Lecture (Nov 2026) [1].
- In West Bengal, per Quraishi: 27 lakh deleted, 22 lakh appealed, 1,607 restored before the poll [1].
- Ashok Lavasa is a former Election Commissioner known for recorded dissent [1].
8. Mains Relevance
- GS-II: Salient features of the RPA; appointment to constitutional posts and the powers, functions and responsibilities of constitutional bodies (ECI); transparency and accountability.
- GS-IV: Probity in governance; institutional integrity.
- Possible question stems: 1. "The power to revise electoral rolls must be balanced against the citizen's right to vote." Discuss in light of the Special Intensive Revision. 2. Examine whether an independent audit and disclosure of decision records are necessary to protect the credibility of the Election Commission of India. 3. "Procedural delays can turn into disenfranchisement." Critically analyse with reference to recent electoral roll revisions.
9. Related Topics to Study Next
- Art. 324 and the ECI's independence: the appointment process, and Anoop Baranwal v. UoI (2023) [3].
- The CEC & ECs Act, 2023: it changes how the selection committee is composed.
- RPA 1950 vs RPA 1951: the two laws split rolls from conduct of elections.
- Citizenship and the electoral roll: the documents demanded during verification raise this link.
- Election data transparency: Form 17C and the 2024 turnout controversy.
- Model Code of Conduct enforcement: this was the context of the Lavasa dissent.
- Electoral reforms: Law Commission and Second ARC recommendations.
- The right to vote as a statutory right vs a constitutional right: a frequent debate topic.
10. NCERT Concepts to Revise
- Special Intensive Revision (Polity): This is the exercise whose deletions and decision records Quraishi wants audited.
- Electoral roll (Polity): The deleted names were removed from this list of eligible voters.
- Representation of the People Act 1950 (Polity): This law governs preparing and revising electoral rolls, including special revision.
- Registration of Electors Rules 1960 (Polity): These rules set the procedure for deletion with notice, claims and appeals.
- Election Commission of India (Polity): The ECI ran the SIR, and its credibility is what is being questioned.
- Universal adult franchise (Polity): Wrongful deletion takes away the Article 326 right of adults to vote.
- Right to vote (Polity): Explains the debate over whether voting is a statutory or constitutional right.
- Appellate tribunal (Polity): Tribunals heard the excluded voters' appeals and found most exclusions incorrect.
- Intensive revision of electoral rolls (Polity): Explains how an intensive revision differs from the yearly summary revision.
- Transparency (Polity): Disclosing decision records and audit trails is a demand for openness in decisions.
- Accountability (Polity): An independent audit would make the ECI answerable for its deletions.
- Electoral Registration Officer (Polity): The ERO is the officer who decides whether a name is deleted.
- Constitutional body (Polity): Helps explain why the independence and credibility of bodies like the ECI matter.
- Representation of the People Act 1951 (Polity): Helps avoid the common trap of confusing it with the 1950 Act on rolls.
- Supreme Court of India (Polity): The Court ruled on the Bihar SIR challenge and could have let appellants vote.
11. Common Errors / Trap Areas
- RPA 1950 vs 1951: rolls fall under 1950; conduct of elections and disqualifications fall under 1951 [3].
- Special vs intensive vs summary revision: Sec. 21(3) is the special-revision power. "Intensive" describes the method (fresh enumeration), not a separate section [3].
- Art. 324 vs Art. 326: 324 is about the institution; 326 is about the voter's entitlement [3].
- Bihar vs West Bengal: the SIR began in Bihar (June 2025). The 27 lakh, 22 lakh and 1,607 figures relate to West Bengal [1][2].
- Units: 27 lakh = 2.7 million, and 1.2 lakh = 120,000. Do not mix up lakh, crore and million [1].
Sources
- 1"Former CEC calls for disclosure of SIR decision records", Ishita Mishra, The Hindu, 21 Nov 2026, p. 3thehindu.com · tier 4
- 2Supreme Court of India, Judgment dated 27 May 2026, Case No. 35785/2025 (challenge to Bihar SIR order of 24.06.2025). Only the search-result title and summary were used; the PDF was not readapi.sci.gov.in · tier 1
- 3: standard provisions of the Constitution of India and RPA 1950. These were not retrieved from a whitelisted URL in this session; check them against indiacode.nic.in or legislative.gov.in before relying on them.