·The Hindu

Rebalancing India’s rice economy

FlashcardsQuick reviseKey facts. One by one.Start →
In this note
  1. At a Glance
  2. Why in the News
  3. Background & Evolution
  4. Core Static Facts
  5. Multi-Dimensional Analysis
  6. Recent Developments (last 12–18 months)
  7. Prelims Hooks
  8. Exports Are Not What Is Draining Punjab's Water
  9. Why Punjab's Farmers Keep Going Back to Paddy
  10. What the Export Value Figures Do Not Show
  11. Who Must Act, and on What
  12. Anchors for Answers
  13. Mains Relevance
  14. Related Topics to Study Next
  15. NCERT Concepts to Revise
  16. Common Errors / Trap Areas
Practice
4 questions on this article
Check the answer for each question, or reveal all at once.
Practice MCQs →

1. At a Glance

  • Policy paradox: India is the world's largest rice exporter, but production in several major rice-growing regions uses a lot of water and other natural resources. That raises questions about whether current output and exports can last. [1]
  • Exports should be judged not just by volume and foreign-exchange earnings but also by the water and environmental resources embedded in them (the idea of virtual water). [1]
  • Proposed shift: from volume to value, meaning "more crop per drop, more income per tonne, and less energy use per unit exported", through a differentiated production strategy. [1]
  • UPSC relevance: this links cropping patterns, irrigation, agricultural exports, food security and resource sustainability (GS-III), and the geography of where crops are grown (GS-I).

2. Why in the News

  • Op-ed "Rebalancing India's rice economy" by A.V. Manjunatha and Vikram Patil, The Hindu, 16 November 2026, page 10 (International edition). [1]
  • The trigger is record output: about 154.02 million tonnes (MT) of rice in 2025-26, with exports reaching 21.57 MT in the same year. [1]

3. Background & Evolution

  • India has been the world's largest rice exporter since 2012. [1]
  • Its share of global rice exports has been about 30–35% in recent years. [1]
  • Export trajectory: 17.73 MT (2020-21) → 21.57 MT (2025-26). [1]
  • Export value trajectory: $8.82 billion (2020-21) → $11.54 billion (2025-26). [1]
  • A government (PIB-hosted) document from March 2026 reports 2024-25 rice export value of about USD 12.95 billion. [2]
  • Note: the 2023–24 export curbs on non-basmati rice and their later relaxation are a relevant earlier policy episode. The whitelisted sources searched did not return their exact dates or terms, so check them against DGFT or PIB notifications before using them.

4. Core Static Facts

Item Fact
Production (2025-26, estimate) 154.02 MT [1]
Leading producing States UP, Telangana, West Bengal, Punjab, Chhattisgarh, Odisha, MP, Bihar, Andhra Pradesh, Tamil Nadu [1]
Global export rank No. 1 since 2012 [1]
Global export share about 30–35% in recent years [1]
Export volume 17.73 MT (2020-21) → 21.57 MT (2025-26) [1]
Export value $8.82 bn (2020-21) → $11.54 bn (2025-26) [1]
Export value 2024-25 (govt document) about USD 12.95 bn [2]
Export basket segments Premium Basmati and high-volume non-Basmati [1]
Export-data agency cited APEDA (Agricultural and Processed Food Products Export Development Authority) [1]
  • Derived from [1] figures:
  • Volume grew about 21.7% while value grew about 30.8%.
  • Implied average unit value rose from about $497/t to about $535/t.
  • Value rising faster than volume is what the article calls "value and volume tell different stories". [1]

5. Multi-Dimensional Analysis

Economic

  • Rice brings in significant foreign exchange: $11.54 bn in 2025-26. [1]
  • The two-tier basket means the high-value Basmati segment and the bulk non-Basmati segment need different strategies. [1]
  • The proposed goal is income per tonne, not tonnage. [1]

Environmental

  • Several major rice regions rely heavily on water. Exporting rice effectively ships out embedded water and natural resources. [1]
  • The article calls for less energy use per unit exported, which points to the energy used for irrigation pumping. [1]

Geographic / Regional

  • Production is spread across very different ecologies: Punjab and UP in the north-west and Indo-Gangetic plain, Odisha, Chhattisgarh and West Bengal in the east, and Telangana, Andhra Pradesh and Tamil Nadu in the south. [1]
  • This variety is why a differentiated, region-specific strategy is needed rather than one uniform national approach. [1]

Strategic / Trade

  • With a 30–35% share of world exports, India's policy choices affect global supplies and prices. [1]
  • Long-term competitiveness has been proved. The next challenge is making it sustainable. [1]

Governance / Administrative

  • Success measures need to go beyond export volume and value to include water and environmental resource use. [1]
  • Policy needs to target crop per drop (water productivity) and not just yield. [1]

6. Recent Developments (last 12–18 months)

  • March 2026: A government document on pib.gov.in records 2024-25 rice export value of about USD 12.95 bn. [2]
  • 2025-26: Production estimated at 154.02 MT, and exports at 21.57 MT worth $11.54 bn. [1]
  • 16 November 2026: The Hindu op-ed calls for rebalancing from volume to value. [1]

7. Prelims Hooks

  • India has been the world's largest rice exporter since 2012. [1]
  • India accounts for about 30–35% of global rice exports. [1]
  • Estimated rice production in 2025-26 was 154.02 MT. [1]
  • Rice exports in 2025-26 were 21.57 MT. [1]
  • Rice export value in 2025-26 was $11.54 billion. [1]
  • Rice exports in 2020-21 were 17.73 MT, worth $8.82 billion. [1]
  • APEDA is the source of rice export data. Full form: Agricultural and Processed Food Products Export Development Authority. [1]
  • The rice export basket has two segments: Basmati (premium) and non-Basmati (high-volume). [1]
  • Telangana is listed among the top rice-producing States alongside UP, West Bengal and Punjab. [1]
  • The slogan "More crop per drop" is tied to water-use efficiency in rice. [1]
  • 2024-25 rice export value was about USD 12.95 bn (government document). [2]

8. Exports Are Not What Is Draining Punjab's Water

  • The strongest objection to the article: cutting exports would save very little water
  • India grew 154.02 MT of rice in 2025-26 and exported 21.57 MT [1].
  • So only about 14% of the rice left the country. About 86% stayed in India, mostly for home use and government stocks.
  • Even if every export stopped, most of the paddy, and most of the water used to grow it, would still be there.

  • The real reason paddy is grown in dry regions is the price signal (what the market or the government tells the farmer through prices) at home

  • A parliamentary water panel noted that water-hungry crops like paddy and sugarcane get a higher MSP (Minimum Support Price, the price at which the government promises to buy). This pushes farmers to depend on groundwater [5].
  • In Punjab and Haryana, officials and experts link the dominance of paddy to free power and subsidised pumps [3].
  • Free power means pumping water costs the farmer almost nothing. So water is overused whether the grain is exported or not.

  • The damage is already measurable

  • The Central Ground Water Board's 2024 assessment puts Punjab's groundwater extraction at about 156% of its yearly recharge (the water that refills the ground each year), the highest of any State [9].
  • Over 100% means the State takes out more water each year than nature puts back.

  • What the article gets right, even so

  • Virtual water (the water used to grow a product, which leaves the country when the product is sold abroad) is a fair way to count the true cost of exports.
  • But the fix sits mainly in MSP, procurement and power policy. Export policy alone cannot do it. A Mains answer should say this clearly.

9. Why Punjab's Farmers Keep Going Back to Paddy

  • Other crops pay less and carry more risk
  • Maize and moong (green gram) earn less than paddy. The price gap between rice and maize has held back crop diversification (moving land to different crops) [3].
  • In pilot districts, farmers who moved to maize went back to paddy when maize did not get assured MSP buying [3].
  • Paddy has an assured buyer at a fixed price. The other crops do not. The farmer is making a sensible choice, not an ignorant one.

  • Diversification schemes have run for years, but the incentives behind them never changed

  • The Centre has tried to move paddy area to pulses, oilseeds, coarse cereals, nutri-cereals and cotton [8].
  • States can fund this under RKVY (Rashtriya Krishi Vikas Yojana, a central scheme that gives States money for agriculture). Projects need approval from a State committee headed by the Chief Secretary [8].
  • In February 2024 a parliamentary Standing Committee observed that public policy still gives too little help to farmers who want to diversify [7].
  • The schemes offer small one-time help. MSP and free power reward paddy every single season.

  • Rules on water alone will not be enough

  • An ICAR (Indian Council of Agricultural Research) scientist argues that changing irrigation policy is needed but is not sufficient. Farmers need a money reason to stop overusing groundwater [4].

10. What the Export Value Figures Do Not Show

  • The 'value is rising' story depends on which years you compare
  • From 2020-21 to 2025-26, export value rose from $8.82 bn to $11.54 bn [1].
  • But a government document puts 2024-25 export value at about $12.95 bn [2].
  • If both numbers measure the same thing, earnings fell by about $1.4 bn in a single year, while volume reached a record [1][2].
  • So 'more income per tonne' is a goal the data does not yet show. Check the definitions (rice type, financial year or calendar year) before you claim a trend.

  • A volume-to-value plan needs India to be a steady seller

  • India banned exports of non-Basmati white rice in July 2023 to keep prices low at home. The ban was lifted only in September 2024 [10].
  • Buyers who pay a premium want supply they can rely on. A ban that can come at any moment works against the 'value' strategy the article proposes.
  • Food security at home will always come first, so India needs clear, rule-based triggers for export curbs, not sudden bans.

11. Who Must Act, and on What

  • Centre and States: pay farmers to switch, every season, not once
  • Past diversification help under RKVY did not beat the assured MSP for paddy [3][8].
  • The Food and Agriculture Ministries should offer assured buying or a yearly payment per hectare for crops that replace paddy in over-exploited blocks (areas where more groundwater is taken out than is refilled).
  • Without assured buying, the maize pilot shows that farmers go back to paddy [3].

  • State governments: change the price of power, gently

  • Free farm power is linked to paddy's dominance [3].
  • Metering power and returning the money saved to the farmer as cash is one way to give the 'financial motivation' the ICAR scientist calls for, without making farming cost more [4].

  • ICAR and the Agriculture Ministry: breed for water, not only for yield

  • The Standing Committee on Agriculture, Animal Husbandry and Food Processing (Chair: Charanjit Singh Channi) reported on research into water-efficient seed varieties to save groundwater on 27 March 2026 [6].
  • Short-duration and low-water varieties put 'more crop per drop' into practice directly.

  • Centre: one body for water decisions

  • A parliamentary panel recommended a new central body because the water agencies do not coordinate [5].
  • Today the agriculture, food, power and water departments each set their own targets, and those targets pull in different directions on paddy.

12. Anchors for Answers

  • Data: Punjab extracts about 156% of its yearly groundwater recharge, the highest of any State (CGWB 2024) [9]
  • Data: Only about 14% of rice output was exported in 2025-26 (21.57 MT of 154.02 MT) [1]
  • Data: Rice export value of about $12.95 bn in 2024-25 [2] against $11.54 bn in 2025-26 [1]
  • Report/Committee: Standing Committee on Agriculture, 'Research for Developing Water Efficient Variety of Seeds to Save Ground Water', 27 March 2026 [6]
  • Report/Committee: Standing Committee on Agriculture, Promotion of Climate Resilient Farming, February 2024: too little help for diversification [7]
  • Scheme: Crop diversification under RKVY, which aims to move paddy area to pulses, oilseeds and nutri-cereals [8]
  • Policy episode: Ban on non-Basmati white rice exports, July 2023 to September 2024 [10]

13. Mains Relevance

14. Related Topics to Study Next

  • Virtual water trade: the core idea behind treating exports as embedded water.
  • Groundwater depletion in north-west India: rice irrigation drives aquifer stress.
  • Crop diversification (paddy to millets or pulses): the main way to rebalance production.
  • Direct Seeded Rice (DSR) and Alternate Wetting & Drying (AWD): water-saving rice techniques.
  • MSP and procurement policy: price signals that encourage rice monoculture.
  • Basmati Geographical Indication (GI) and value-added exports: central to the volume-to-value shift.
  • WTO and public stockholding: links food security stocks to trade rules.
  • Methane emissions from paddy: the climate side of rice sustainability.

15. NCERT Concepts to Revise

  • Virtual water (Economy): Core idea of the article: exporting rice effectively exports the water used to grow it.
  • Rice (Geography): The crop at the centre of the article: where it is grown and how much.
  • Export (Economy): India's rice exports and their volume versus value are the article's main subject.
  • Groundwater depletion (Geography): Water-hungry paddy in Punjab and Haryana is draining aquifers, which raises sustainability concerns.
  • Crop diversification (Economy): Moving some area from paddy to other crops is the main way to rebalance production.
  • Direct seeded rice (Economy): A water-saving method that supports the 'more crop per drop' goal.
  • Basmati rice (Geography): The premium export segment; GI-backed value addition is central to shifting from volume to value.
  • Geographical indication (Economy): GI tags help Basmati fetch higher prices, supporting more income per tonne.
  • Sustainable development (Economy): The article asks whether current rice output and exports can last without harming future resources.
  • Food security (Economy): Rice is a staple, so export policy has to be weighed against domestic food security.
  • Agricultural and Processed Food Products Export Development Authority (Economy): APEDA is the body that promotes agri-exports and supplies the export data cited.
  • Irrigated farming (Geography): Rice growing in much of India depends on canals and tubewells, which drives the heavy water use.
  • Procurement (Economy): Assured government purchase of rice at MSP encourages paddy cultivation even in water-scarce regions.
  • Price signals (Economy): Prices and MSP tell farmers what to grow, so they explain the paddy monoculture.
  • Foreign exchange (Economy): Rice exports earn about $11.5 billion a year in foreign exchange.

16. Common Errors / Trap Areas

  • Producer vs exporter: The article's "since 2012" claim is about exports. Do not mix it up with the global production ranking.
  • Units and years: Volume is in million tonnes (MT) and value in US$ bn. The 2020-21 baseline (17.73 MT, $8.82 bn) and the 2025-26 figures (21.57 MT, $11.54 bn) are easy to swap. [1]
  • Conflicting value figures: The 2024-25 value of about $12.95 bn [2] is higher than the 2025-26 value of $11.54 bn [1]. Check the definitions (rice category, fiscal or calendar year) before quoting a trend.
  • Top-State lists: Telangana and Chhattisgarh are major producers. Aspirants often list only Punjab and West Bengal. [1]
  • APEDA vs FCI: APEDA reports export data. Procurement and buffer stocks are a separate system and should not be confused with it.

Sources

  1. 1The Hindu, "Rebalancing India's rice economy" (A.V. Manjunatha, Vikram Patil), 16 Nov 2026, p. 10thehindu.com · tier 4
  2. 2PIB document (March 2026), rice export value 2024-25static.pib.gov.in · tier 1
  3. 3Punjab and Haryana are unable to get out of paddy-wheat cycle; why is that? (Down To Earth)downtoearth.org.in · tier 4
  4. 4India's farmers need financial motivation to check indiscriminate use of groundwater for irrigation (Down To Earth)downtoearth.org.in · tier 4
  5. 5Panel recommends new central body to mitigate water woes due to lack of agency coordination (Down To Earth)downtoearth.org.in · tier 4
  6. 6PRS Standing Committee Report Summary: Research for Developing Water Efficient Variety of Seeds to Save Groundwaterprsindia.org · tier 1
  7. 7PRS Standing Committee Report Summary: Promotion of Climate Resilient Farmingprsindia.org · tier 1
  8. 8PIB, Ministry of Agriculture & Farmers Welfare: Measures to Promote Crop Diversificationpib.gov.in · tier 1
  9. 9CGWB: Dynamic Ground Water Resources of Punjab, 2024cgwb.gov.in · tier 1
  10. 10Rice stocks surge after govt announces removal of ban on export of non-basmati rice (Business Standard)business-standard.com · tier 4
At the end · practice MCQs
4 questions on this article
Check the answer for each question, or reveal all at once.
Practice MCQs →

Mains Q&A on this note

NCERT concepts in this note

Also on 16 November

All 16 November articles →