Royal Commission on Agriculture
Also called: Linlithgow Commission on Agriculture · Topic: Colonial Economy: Land Revenue, Drain, Deindustrialisation · NCERT: Beyond NCERT
Meaning
The Royal Commission on Agriculture (also called the Linlithgow Commission) was a body set up by the British Crown in 1926. It was chaired by Lord Linlithgow and studied Indian farming and village life. It gave its report in 1928, and the report led to the Imperial Council of Agricultural Research in 1929.
It matters because it was the colonial government's biggest review of Indian agriculture. It was also told not to look at land ownership, tenancy (renting of land) and land revenue, which were the main causes of rural poverty. So its fixes were technical. They did not change the basic structure of the rural economy.
Explanation
Background: why a commission in 1926?
- The countryside was already poor and in debt.
- The Permanent Settlement (1793, Bengal) and ryotwari (from 1818, Bombay Deccan) set high revenue demands.
-
Ryotwari (revenue settled directly with each peasant, called the ryot) pushed peasants to moneylenders. By the 1840s officials were already reporting alarming rural debt.
-
Famines had killed millions. Examples are Bengal in 1770–72 and the Great Famine of 1876–78. Officials blamed nature, but nationalists blamed colonial policy.
- Nationalist economists attacked British rule. Dadabhai Naoroji and R.C. Dutt argued that British rule drained India's wealth and kept Indian farming weak.
- The government wanted to look like it was improving farming but did not want to touch its revenue income. A Royal Commission was a safe, expert way to do this.
Who ran it and what it was asked to do
- Chairman: Lord Linlithgow, a British nobleman. He later became Viceroy of India (1936–43).
- Members: a mix of British and Indian experts and officials.
- Its job (terms of reference): to study the state of agriculture and the rural economy and suggest ways to improve farming and the welfare of rural people.
- The big limit: it was not allowed to make proposals on:
- the systems of landownership and tenancy, or
-
how land revenue and irrigation charges were assessed.
-
So the Permanent Settlement, ryotwari, high revenue demand and landlord power were all outside its scope.
Main recommendations (report, 1928)
- Agricultural research: set up a central body to plan and fund research across India. This led to the Imperial Council of Agricultural Research (1929). After Independence it became the Indian Council of Agricultural Research (ICAR).
- Cooperatives: make the cooperative movement (village societies where members pool money and give each other cheap loans) stronger, to cut dependence on moneylenders.
- Marketing: set up regulated markets (official markets with fixed rules on weighing, fees and payment) so traders could not cheat farmers.
- Other areas:
- more irrigation
- better livestock and veterinary services (animal doctors)
- better seeds and manure
- consolidation of holdings (joining small scattered plots into one farm)
- rural roads, village schooling and health
Results and limits
- What changed:
- India got a national research body (the Imperial Council, later ICAR).
-
The work of agriculture departments, cooperatives and regulated markets grew slowly.
-
What did not change:
- Revenue demand, tenancy and landlord power stayed the same.
-
The Great Depression of the 1930s came soon after. Prices crashed and rural debt got worse. The study note says this was when Bengal's zamindars finally collapsed and the jotedars (rich peasants) took over the countryside.
-
Overall: good advice on technique, but a weak remedy, because the deepest causes were deliberately left out.
Time, place and evidence
- Period: late colonial India, between the two World Wars. Appointed 1926, reported 1928.
- Place: all of British India.
- Key person: Lord Linlithgow (chairman, later Viceroy 1936–43).
- Institution it led to: the Imperial Council of Agricultural Research (1929), later ICAR.
- How we know: the Commission's printed Report (1928) and the evidence volumes of witness statements.
- The study note warns that official reports like this, the Fifth Report (1813) and famine commission records must be read with care. Ask who wrote them and why.
- Check them against newspapers, legal records and unofficial accounts.
-
This Commission was barred from looking at land revenue, so its picture of rural India leaves out the state's own role.
-
Colonial farm experiments of the same period: in November 1926, while the Commission was sitting, the Madras government wound up a costly, long-padlocked Government Jam Factory. Part of its machinery went to the Government Dairy Farm at Hosur and part to Sir Frederick Nicholson for fruit-preserving research.
Don't confuse with
- Famine Commission (1878–80): set up after the Great Famine of 1876–78, mainly about famine relief. It warned against treating relief as a right. The Royal Commission on Agriculture (1926–28) looked at farming as a whole.
- Simon Commission (1927): also appointed by the British around the same time, but it was about constitutional reform (how India should be governed), not agriculture.
- Lord Linlithgow as Viceroy (1936–43): the same man. As chairman he led the agriculture commission (1926–28). As Viceroy he dealt with the Second World War and the Quit India Movement. Don't mix up the two roles or their dates.
- Imperial Agricultural Research Institute, Pusa: an older research institute from Curzon's time. The Imperial Council of Agricultural Research (1929) was a new national body to plan and fund research, and it came from the Commission's report.
Prelims Hooks
- Royal Commission on Agriculture: appointed 1926, report 1928, chairman Lord Linlithgow.
- Its main institutional result was the Imperial Council of Agricultural Research (1929), now ICAR.
- Trap (FALSE): "The Commission recommended abolishing the Permanent Settlement." In fact, landownership, tenancy and land revenue were outside its terms of reference.
- Its key ideas were agricultural research, cooperatives, regulated markets, irrigation, veterinary services and consolidation of holdings.
- Chronology: Famine Commission (1878–80), then Royal Commission on Agriculture (1926–28), then the Great Depression hits Indian agriculture (1930s).
- The chairman (Linlithgow) later became Viceroy (1936–43).
Mains Points
- Fixing techniques, not structures.
- The Commission offered research, cooperatives and markets.
- It was not allowed to touch revenue, tenancy or landlordism, which were the roots of rural debt shown by the Permanent Settlement auctions and the ryotwari debt spiral.
-
Use it to argue that colonial farm policy was "more experimental than transformative".
-
Continuity into independent India.
- The Imperial Council became ICAR. Its stress on research, cooperatives and regulated markets carried on after 1947.
-
After 1947 India also did what the Commission was not allowed to do: zamindari abolition and tenancy reform.
-
Reading it as a source.
- Like the Fifth Report, the Commission's report is valuable evidence but is shaped by its makers' interests.
- By leaving out land revenue, it quietly shifted the blame for rural poverty onto "backward" farming methods and away from colonial policy. The drain-of-wealth writers (Naoroji, Dutt) rejected this view.