Constitutional court

Polity & Governance glossary

Also called: Constitutional Court model · Topic: Judiciary: Independence, Structure, Judicial Review and Activism · NCERT: Beyond NCERT

Meaning

A constitutional court is a separate top court that hears only questions about the Constitution. It decides whether laws and government actions fit the Constitution. It does not hear ordinary civil or criminal appeals. Germany and Italy use this model. India does not have one. India's single Supreme Court guards the Constitution and is also the final court of appeal, including through special leave petitions (Art. 136), which are requests for the court's permission to appeal. Supporters say a separate constitutional court would leave the top judges free to focus on big constitutional questions, instead of being buried under a heavy backlog of ordinary appeals.

Example

In 2009 the Law Commission's 229th Report proposed a Constitution Bench in Delhi. It would hear constitutional matters. Four regional cassation benches would take ordinary appeals from the High Courts. A cassation bench is a court that decides only points of law. The Supreme Court's Full Court, a meeting of all its judges, rejected the idea in 2010. A related plea for a National Court of Appeal was sent to a Constitution Bench in 2016 and is still pending.

Don't confuse with

  • Constitution bench: a bench of at least 5 judges of the same Supreme Court, formed under Art. 145(3) for a big constitutional question. It is not a separate court.
  • Regional benches under Art. 130: sittings of the same Supreme Court outside Delhi, set by the CJI with the President's approval. They change where the court sits, not what kind of cases it hears.

Read more