Entry 54, List II (State List)
Also called: Entry 54 State List, State power to tax sale of goods · Topic: Federalism and Centre-State Relations · NCERT: Beyond NCERT
Meaning
Entry 54 of List II (the State List) in the Seventh Schedule gives States the power to tax the sale of goods. Since the 101st Amendment (2016), it covers only six goods: petroleum crude, high speed diesel, petrol, natural gas, aviation turbine fuel (ATF) and alcoholic liquor for human consumption. Sales in inter-State trade and in international trade are excluded.
It matters because these six goods stay outside GST. That makes Entry 54 one of the few taxes a State still controls on its own, and a large part of State revenue depends on it.
Explanation
Before and after GST
- Old Entry 54 (before 2016)
- It let States tax the "sale or purchase of goods" (other than newspapers). This was the base for State sales tax and VAT.
-
It was subject to the Union's power over inter-State sales in the Union List.
-
New Entry 54 (after the 101st Amendment, 2016)
- The amendment replaced the old entry with a much narrower one.
- It now names only six goods: petroleum crude, high speed diesel, petrol, natural gas, ATF and alcoholic liquor for human consumption.
- The new text speaks only of the "sale" of these goods. The word "purchase" is gone.
-
It does not cover sales in the course of inter-State trade or international trade.
-
Why the entry shrank
- GST brought in a concurrent taxing power (Art. 246A). This means Parliament and the States both tax the same supply of goods and services at the same time.
- Most goods moved into GST. Only these six stayed with the States under Entry 54.
Why the six goods stay outside GST
- Alcohol is left out permanently
- The Constitution defines GST as a tax on any supply of goods or services except alcoholic liquor for human consumption.
-
So alcohol can come into GST only through another constitutional amendment.
-
The five petroleum products are only on hold
- They are legally inside GST, but GST will apply to them only from a date the GST Council (Art. 279A) recommends.
-
Until that date, States keep taxing them under Entry 54.
-
Tobacco was dropped
- The 2014 GST Bill (122nd Amendment Bill) had tobacco in its draft of Entry 54.
- The Act passed in 2016 left tobacco out.
What States can do under it
- Set their own rate. Under GST, no single State can change a rate; the GST Council fixes rates for everyone. On fuel and liquor sales, each State still decides its own rate.
- Add cesses and surcharges. A cess here is an extra charge worked out as a percentage of the sales tax due.
- S. Kodar v. State of Kerala (1975) held that such an add-on is still a tax on the sale or purchase of goods under Entry 54.
- In November 2026, a seven-judge Constitution Bench reaffirmed Kodar. It held that the add-on is an enhancement of the rate of sales tax (a higher rate of the same tax), not a separate levy.
- The Court rejected the "tax on tax" argument. This argument said a levy measured on tax already payable does not fall on the sale itself.
-
The ruling read Entry 54 "as it then stood", meaning the version before 2016.
-
Limits
- No tax on inter-State or international sales of these goods.
- The levy must really be a tax on sale. Courts check this using pith and substance (they look at the true nature of a law, not its label).
In the Constitution and practice
- Where it sits. Entry 54 is in List II of the Seventh Schedule (Art. 246). It is one of the State tax entries, which run from Entry 45 to Entry 63 of the State List.
- Amendments and laws
- 101st Amendment, 2016: replaced Entry 54 and limited it to six goods. It also added Art. 246A (concurrent GST power), Art. 269A (only Parliament taxes inter-State supplies) and Art. 279A (GST Council). GST began on 1 July 2017.
-
Draft GST Compensation Bill, 2016: revenue from the old Entry 54 on these goods was left out of the base-year revenue used to work out States' compensation. This shows the goods were treated as a separate State revenue stream.
-
Cases
- S. Kodar v. State of Kerala (1975): a cess or surcharge calculated as a percentage of sales tax is valid under Entry 54.
- Seven-judge Bench (November 2026): reaffirmed Kodar. It settled petitions pending since 1994.
-
Mohit Minerals (2022): the GST Council's recommendations are persuasive, not binding. This matters for how much say the Council has over taxes.
-
In practice
- For 2025-26, States expect about 20% of their own tax revenue from sales tax and 14% from State excise (the State tax on alcohol).
- Sales tax and VAT now come mainly from petroleum and alcohol.
- In 2023-24, SGST, sales tax and State excise together made up about 79% of States' own tax revenue.
- In Delhi, the effective tax on petroleum products was about 62% (November 2022).
Don't confuse with
- Entry 51, List II (State excise): Entry 51 taxes the manufacture of alcoholic liquor. Entry 54 taxes its sale. A State uses both on liquor.
- Art. 246A (GST power): under Art. 246A, the Union and the States tax the supply of goods and services together. Under Entry 54, only the State taxes the sale of six goods.
- Inter-State sales (Art. 269A and the Union List): only the Union taxes these. Entry 54 expressly excludes inter-State and international sales.
- Alcohol vs petroleum under GST: alcohol is outside the definition of GST. Petroleum is inside it but deferred until the GST Council recommends a date.
Prelims Hooks
- Entry 54, List II now covers six goods: petroleum crude, high speed diesel, petrol, natural gas, ATF and alcoholic liquor for human consumption.
- The 101st Amendment Act, 2016 replaced Entry 54. Tobacco was in the 2014 Bill's draft but is not in the enacted text.
- Trap: "Entry 54 lets a State tax inter-State sales of petrol." FALSE. Inter-State and international sales are excluded.
- Trap: "Petroleum can come into GST only by a new constitutional amendment." FALSE. The GST Council only has to recommend a date. Alcohol, however, is outside the GST definition.
- Case–principle pair: S. Kodar v. State of Kerala (1975): a cess calculated as a percentage of sales tax is an enhancement of the sales-tax rate. A seven-judge Bench reaffirmed this in 2026.
- The new Entry 54 says "sale" only. The old entry said "sale or purchase".
Mains Points
- Fiscal autonomy vs a single national market
- Entry 54 is the main tax lever States have left after GST, because they set the rate and can add cesses.
- Keeping fuel outside GST means businesses cannot set off the tax paid on fuel against their GST. This cost passes into prices across the economy.
-
The ruling that cesses are valid gives States one more reason to resist bringing petroleum into GST.
-
Cesses on both sides of the federation
- The Union's cesses are left out of the divisible pool (the share of Union tax revenue that goes to States). As a result, the States' 41% share works out to only about 32% of gross tax revenue (2024-25 BE).
-
States now use the same tool on fuel and liquor. Stacked levies are easy to raise and hide the true rate from the buyer.
-
Reforms
- The GST Council could set a roadmap to bring petroleum into GST, with a time-bound revenue guarantee for States, modelled on the 2016 compensation law.
- The Union could limit cesses kept outside the divisible pool.
- States could publish one combined effective rate on fuel and liquor.
- Tax references to Constitution Benches need fixed hearing dates; the Kodar reference waited from 1994 to 2026.