Extrajudicial killing
Also called: Extrajudicial execution · Topic: Fundamental Rights and Constitutional Remedies · NCERT: Beyond NCERT
Meaning
An extrajudicial killing is a killing by state agents, such as police or security forces, without any court trial or legal sentence. "Extrajudicial" means "outside the judicial process". In India, it is often called a fake encounter: the police claim they fired in self-defence, but the shooting was planned. It breaks Article 21, which says no person shall lose their life "except according to procedure established by law". Since Maneka Gandhi (1978), that procedure must be "right, just and fair". Article 21 protects every person, citizen or not, and cannot be suspended even in an emergency. Courts can order the State to pay compensation for such violations. In Nilabati Behera (1993), the Supreme Court held that the State cannot escape paying by claiming sovereign immunity, the old idea that the government cannot be sued.
Example
In 2025, a UN fact-finding report found that Bangladesh's former government carried out extrajudicial killings while putting down the 2024 student protests. The UN estimated that around 1,400 people may have been killed. In India, a common case is a suspect in police custody who is shot dead "while trying to escape". Courts and the NHRC can inquire into such killings.
Don't confuse with
- Death penalty: this is a sentence given by a court after a full trial. It is allowed only in the "rarest of rare" cases (Bachan Singh, 1980). An extrajudicial killing has no trial at all.
- Custodial violence: this means torture or abuse of a person held by the police, which may or may not end in death. The D.K. Basu guidelines (1997) were framed to prevent it.