Games of skill versus games of chance
Also called: Skill vs chance test, Dominant factor test · Topic: Fundamental Rights and Constitutional Remedies · NCERT: Beyond NCERT
Meaning
For decades, Indian law split games into two kinds. A game of skill is one where winning depends mostly on the player's knowledge, practice and judgment. A game of chance is one where winning depends mostly on luck. Courts used the dominant factor test: they asked whether skill or luck mainly decides the result. Skill games were treated as a lawful business under Article 19(1)(g), which protects the right to carry on any trade. Chance games played for money were treated as gambling. The Promotion and Regulation of Online Gaming (PROG) Act, 2025 moved this line for online games. The Act calls any game where a player pays a fee or deposit hoping to win money an "online money game", and it bans all of them. It does not matter whether the game needs skill or depends on luck.
Example
Courts had earlier treated online rummy and fantasy cricket as games of skill. Under the PROG Act, 2025, both are now banned in the same way as betting games, because players put money in to win money. In May 2026, the Supreme Court upheld Tamil Nadu and Karnataka laws banning online games played for stakes. It said that once money is staked, the skill-versus-chance difference matters much less.
Don't confuse with
- E-sports and online social games: these are allowed under the PROG framework. The test is whether money is staked, not whether skill is involved. A skill game becomes banned only when players pay to win money.