Hostile witness

Polity & Governance glossary

Also called: Turning hostile · Topic: Justice Delivery: Subordinate Courts, Tribunals, Legal Aid and Judicial Reforms · NCERT: Beyond NCERT

Meaning

A hostile witness is a witness who goes back on what they said earlier, usually in their statement to the police. They may also simply stop supporting the side that called them to court. When this happens, the court can let the side that called the witness question them sharply, as if they were the other side's witness. Witnesses often turn hostile because trials drag on for years, or because the accused threatens or bribes them. This weakens trials, so the law now has a Witness Protection Scheme 2018, approved by the Supreme Court in Mahender Chawla, to keep witnesses safe. The BNSS (s.398) also requires states to notify such schemes.

Example

The Class 11 NCERT chapter on the Judiciary warns that witnesses often change their testimony "to suit the wealthy and the mighty". For example, the main eyewitness to an assault tells the police she saw the accused strike the victim. Years later, after threats, she tells the court she saw nothing, and the prosecution's case falls apart.

Don't confuse with

  • False evidence (perjury): this means knowingly lying under oath, and it is a crime. Turning hostile does not by itself prove that the witness lied. The court decides which version to believe, and it can still rely on the parts of a hostile witness's evidence that seem true.

Read more