Impunity

Polity & Governance glossary

Topic: Transparency, Accountability and e-Governance · NCERT: Beyond NCERT

Meaning

Impunity means doing something wrong and facing no punishment or consequence for it. The wrongdoer is never investigated, never tried in court, or never made to answer for the act. It is the opposite of accountability. Accountability has two parts: answerability (having to explain your actions) and enforceability (having to face the consequences). Impunity is what happens when enforceability fails. It matters because once the powerful believe nothing will happen to them, the rule of law weakens and abuses repeat.

Example

In the Pegasus case (Manohar Lal Sharma v. UoI, 27 October 2021), the Supreme Court held that the State gets no "free pass" just by citing national security. The Court did not let the matter close on the government's word. It set up a technical committee, supervised by Justice R.V. Raveendran, to examine the claims that the spyware was used on people's phones. The idea behind the judgment is to deny impunity: even the State must answer for alleged surveillance.

Don't confuse with

  • Immunity: a protection that the law itself grants. For example, Art. 361 of the Constitution protects the President and Governors from court cases while in office. Immunity is lawful and written down. Impunity means escaping punishment in practice, usually when the law should have applied.

Read more