Legislative competence

Polity & Governance glossary

Also called: Legislative entries, Competence of legislature · Topic: Federalism and Centre-State Relations · NCERT: Beyond NCERT

Meaning

Legislative competence is a legislature's legal power to make a law on a subject. For a subject to be within competence, three things must hold:

  • the Constitution gives that subject to the legislature, mainly through the entries of the Seventh Schedule read with Articles 245-248;
  • the law stays inside the legislature's territory;
  • no other provision of the Constitution stops it.

It matters because federalism depends on it. If Parliament or a state legislature makes a law outside its competence, the law is ultra vires (beyond its powers), and a court can strike it down as void.

Explanation

Where the power comes from

  • The power to legislate comes from the Articles, not from the entries.
  • Article 245 sets the territory. Parliament can make laws for the whole or any part of India. A state legislature can make laws for the whole or any part of its state.
  • Article 246 gives the subjects through the three lists of the Seventh Schedule.
  • The entries only mark out fields (areas of subject matter). Courts read them broadly, not narrowly.

  • Who gets which list (Article 246):

  • Union List (List I): only Parliament. Examples are defence, foreign affairs, banking, currency, railways and atomic energy.
  • State List (List II): only the state legislature, in normal times. Examples are police, public order, agriculture, land, public health and liquor.
  • Concurrent List (List III): both Parliament and the states. Examples are education, forests, marriage, criminal law and electricity.
  • The lists began with 97, 66 and 47 entries.

  • Overlap rule: where the lists overlap, the Union List wins.

  • Residuary power (Article 248; Union List entry 97): a subject that is in no list belongs to Parliament. Examples are cyber laws and computer software.
  • Special power for GST (Article 246A): Parliament and the states can both tax the same supply of goods and services. Only Parliament can tax inter-state supplies (Article 269A).

Taxing competence is separate

  • The Constitution gives taxing power through its own tax entries.
  • Union List entries 82-92C and State List entries 45-63 are the tax entries.
  • So a power to regulate a subject does not by itself give a power to tax it. The tax power must come from a tax entry.

  • Entry 54 of the State List (tax on the sale or purchase of goods) is a key example.

  • The 101st Amendment (2016) replaced it with a narrower entry.
  • It now covers only six goods: petroleum crude, high speed diesel, petrol, natural gas, aviation turbine fuel, and alcoholic liquor for human consumption.
  • It does not cover sales in the course of inter-State trade or international trade.

How courts test competence

When a law is challenged, the court first finds which entry the law truly belongs to. It then asks whether that entry belongs to the legislature that made the law. The court uses three main doctrines (rules of interpretation):

  • Pith and substance: the court looks at the law's true nature, not its label.
  • If the core of the law falls in the legislature's own list, the law is valid.
  • A side effect on another list does not make it invalid (Prafulla Kumar Mukherjee, 1947; F.N. Balsara, 1951).

  • Colourable legislation: a legislature cannot do indirectly what it cannot do directly (K.C. Gajapati Narayan Deo, 1953).

  • The question is whether the legislature has the power. Its motive does not decide the question.

  • Territorial nexus: a state law can reach things outside the state only if there is a real link to the state (R.M.D. Chamarbaugwala, 1957).

  • Parliament's laws are not invalid just because they act outside India (Article 245(2)).

When Parliament's competence grows

Parliament can make laws on State List subjects in four situations:

Article Trigger Condition
249 National interest The Rajya Sabha passes a resolution by two-thirds of members present and voting. It lasts 1 year and can be renewed. The law lapses 6 months after the resolution ends.
250 National emergency The law lapses 6 months after the emergency ends.
252 Consent of states Two or more state legislatures ask for the law. Other states can adopt it later. Only Parliament can amend it.
253 International agreements Parliament can make a law on any subject to carry out a treaty.
  • Under Article 357, Parliament can also make laws for a state that is under President's rule (when the Union takes over the running of a state for a time, under Article 356).
  • The reverse power does not exist. A state legislature can never enter the Union List.

In the Constitution and practice

  • Constitutional base:
  • Articles 245-248 and Article 246A (added by the 101st Amendment, 2016);
  • the Seventh Schedule;
  • Articles 249-253, which widen Parliament's competence;
  • Article 254, which settles clashes on Concurrent List subjects.

  • The 42nd Amendment (1976) moved five subjects from the State List to the Concurrent List:

  • education;
  • forests;
  • weights and measures;
  • protection of wild animals and birds;
  • administration of justice.

It also added population control and family planning. Parliament got competence in these fields, but states did not lose theirs.

  • Who raises the question: competence is the usual ground for challenging Union or state laws before the High Courts and the Supreme Court. Disputes between the Union and states can also come as Article 131 suits.
  • Examples of laws made under the widening powers:
  • Article 252: Wild Life (Protection) Act 1972 and Water Act 1974.
  • Article 253: Air Act 1981 and Environment (Protection) Act 1986.

  • Recent rulings in favour of states:

  • Mineral Area Development Authority v. SAIL (2024) held that royalty is not a tax, so states have competence to tax minerals.
  • Lalta Prasad Vaish (2024) placed industrial alcohol under State List entry 8.
  • Jindal Stainless (2016, nine judges) upheld non-discriminatory entry taxes levied by states.

  • Cess on sales tax (November 2026):

  • A seven-judge Constitution Bench held that an additional tax, surcharge or cess that a state sets as a percentage of the sales tax payable is within the state's legislative competence under Entry 54, List II.
  • It reaffirmed S. Kodar v. State of Kerala (1975). Such a levy is an enhancement of the sales-tax rate, not a separate "tax on tax".
  • The ruling read Entry 54 as it stood before 2016.

  • Concurrent List laws in the news: the farm laws (2020, repealed 2021) and the new criminal laws (2023) were challenged on federal grounds. The Sarkaria and Punchhi commissions both said the Union should consult states before making laws on Concurrent List subjects.

Don't confuse with

  • Repugnancy (Article 254): this question comes up only when both laws are within competence on a Concurrent List subject and they clash. The Union law then wins, unless the state law was reserved for the President and received the President's assent. A law that lacks competence is void from the start. A repugnant law is valid but gives way to the Union law to the extent of the clash.
  • Violation of Fundamental Rights (Article 13): a law can be fully within competence and still be void because it breaks a Fundamental Right. Competence asks whether this legislature can make the law. Article 13 asks whether any legislature can make it.
  • Colourable legislation: this is not a separate kind of power. It is a test that exposes a lack of competence hidden behind a law's form. It does not punish bad motive.
  • Residuary power (Article 248): this covers subjects that are in no list. Ordinary competence comes from a named entry. India gives residuary power to the Union, as Canada does. The USA gives it to the states.

Prelims Hooks

  • Article 245: territorial extent of laws. Article 246: subject-wise division of power through the Seventh Schedule. Article 248: residuary power with Parliament.
  • Case-principle pairs: Balsara (1951) is pith and substance; Gajapati Narayan Deo (1953) is colourable legislation; R.M.D. Chamarbaugwala (1957) is territorial nexus; M. Karunanidhi (1979) is repugnancy.
  • Trap: "Article 249 needs consent of two or more states." FALSE. That is Article 252. Article 249 needs a Rajya Sabha resolution by two-thirds of members present and voting.
  • The 42nd Amendment (1976) moved five subjects from the State List to the Concurrent List, including education and forests.
  • After the 101st Amendment (2016), Entry 54 of the State List covers only six goods: petroleum crude, HSD, petrol, natural gas, ATF and alcoholic liquor for human consumption.
  • A seven-judge Bench (2026) reaffirmed S. Kodar (1975): a state's cess set as a percentage of sales tax is within its competence under Entry 54, List II.

Mains Points

  • Courts as umpire of federalism:
  • Doctrines such as pith and substance let laws work even when they touch another list. This avoids rigid compartments between the lists.
  • Recent rulings (MADA v. SAIL, 2024; Lalta Prasad Vaish, 2024; Kodar reaffirmed, 2026) show courts protecting the states' share of competence, especially their taxing power.

  • A design tilted to the Union:

  • The longer Union List, residuary power, the 42nd Amendment's transfers and Articles 249-253 all let Parliament's competence grow at the cost of the states.
  • Reform asked for:

    • the Rajamannar Committee (1969/71) wanted residuary powers for the states;
    • Sarkaria and Punchhi wanted the Union to consult states before Concurrent List laws.
  • Fiscal side of competence:

  • After GST, states can tax the sale of only petroleum and alcohol under Entry 54. That makes their competence to add cesses on these goods vital for their revenue.
  • The trade-off:
    • the cess power protects state fiscal autonomy;
    • stacked levies hide the true tax rate;
    • they also make it harder to bring petroleum into GST.

Read more