Misbehaviour
Also called: Proved misbehaviour · Topic: Judiciary: Independence, Structure, Judicial Review and Activism · NCERT: Beyond NCERT
Meaning
Misbehaviour is one of only two grounds for removing a Supreme Court judge under Art. 124(4). The other is incapacity. The same grounds apply to High Court judges (Art. 218) and to the Chief Election Commissioner (Art. 324(5)). It means serious personal wrongdoing in office. A judgment or decision that people disagree with is not misbehaviour. The Constitution says it must be proved. Under the Judges (Inquiry) Act 1968, a three-member committee checks the charges: a Supreme Court judge, a High Court Chief Justice and a distinguished jurist. Parliament can vote on removal only if this committee finds the person guilty. The bar is set this high so that no government can remove a judge just for giving rulings it dislikes.
Example
In 1991, 108 MPs signed a notice to remove Justice V. Ramaswami. In 1992 the Sawant committee found "wilful and gross misuse of office", so misbehaviour was proved. Even so, the Lok Sabha vote in May 1993 failed because the Congress abstained (stayed away from voting), so he was not removed.
Don't confuse with
- Incapacity: this means the person is unable to do the job, for example because of illness of body or mind. Misbehaviour means wrongdoing in office.
- Impeachment: this word is used only for removing the President (Art. 61), and its ground is "violation of the Constitution". Judges are not impeached. They are removed by an "address" (a formal request to the President) passed by both Houses with a special majority.