National Court of Appeal

Polity & Governance glossary

Also called: Court of Appeal · Topic: Justice Delivery: Subordinate Courts, Tribunals, Legal Aid and Judicial Reforms · NCERT: Beyond NCERT

Meaning

A National Court of Appeal is a proposed new court that would sit between the High Courts and the Supreme Court. It would hear ordinary appeals, meaning challenges to High Court decisions in everyday civil and criminal cases. The Supreme Court would then be free to deal mainly with constitutional questions and substantial questions of law, which are important legal points that affect many cases. The Constitution has no such court today. Creating it would probably need a constitutional amendment affecting Articles 124 and 136, and that amendment would have to respect the basic structure (the core features of the Constitution that Parliament cannot change).

Example

In 2016, a writ petition (V. Vasanthakumar) asked for a National Court of Appeal to be set up. On 13 July 2016, the Supreme Court sent the issue to a Constitution Bench, a bench of at least five judges, and framed 11 questions for it. Ten years later the matter is still sub judice, which means it is still pending before the court. Meanwhile, pending cases in the Supreme Court reached a record 92,318 at the end of 2025.

Don't confuse with

  • Regional benches of the Supreme Court: under Article 130, the Chief Justice of India can let the Supreme Court sit outside Delhi, with the President's approval. No amendment is needed. A National Court of Appeal would be a separate, new tier of court.
  • Cassation benches: in 2009, the Law Commission's 229th Report proposed four regional benches of the Supreme Court itself to hear appeals. They would be part of the same court, not a new court.

Read more