National Police Commission
Also called: NPC, Dharma Vira Commission · Topic: Civil Services: Role, Accountability and Reforms · NCERT: Beyond NCERT
Meaning
The National Police Commission (NPC) was a commission headed by Dharma Vira. It worked from 1977 to 1981, produced eight reports, and was the first full review of Indian policing after Independence. Governments largely ignored its reports, but its ideas returned through the Prakash Singh case (2006), which is the basis of police reform today.
Explanation
Why it was set up
- The colonial law was still in force
- Policing still ran under the Police Act 1861, a British-era law built to control people, not to serve them.
-
No full review of the police had been done since 1947.
-
The Emergency (1975-77) showed the danger
- Police and officials carried out illegal detentions and other excesses on political orders.
- The Shah Commission (1978) said officers who obey illegal orders must answer for them.
-
The NPC was set up soon after the Emergency to ask a related question: how can the police be kept away from political misuse?
-
The police and the public did not trust each other
- Even before the NPC, leaders spoke of a "gap between public expectation and police performance".
What it worked on
- Its main concern was political interference. It looked for ways to protect the police from day-to-day political pressure while keeping them answerable to the law.
- Areas it covered across its eight reports:
- how the police should be controlled and supervised;
- transfers, postings and tenure of officers;
- keeping crime investigation separate from law-and-order duty;
- complaints against the police and police accountability;
- replacing the 1861 Act with a new police law.
Limits
- It could only advise. A commission like the NPC can recommend, but it cannot force anyone to act.
- Police is a state subject. "Police" (Entry 2) and "Public order" (Entry 1) are in the State List of the Seventh Schedule. Each state had to adopt the reforms on its own, and most did not.
- States did not want to give up control. The reforms would have taken away their power over police transfers, so the reports stayed on paper.
In the Constitution and practice
- Constitutional setting: police and public order are in the State List (List II, Seventh Schedule). So reform depends on state governments, and the Centre or the courts can only push.
- What happened next: the NPC's eight reports were largely ignored. So were later reviews: the Ribeiro, Padmanabhaiah and Malimath committees.
-
Revived by the Supreme Court: the Prakash Singh case (22 September 2006) turned many of these long-pending ideas into seven binding directives. These included: 1. a State Security Commission (a body to set broad police policy and shield the police from political pressure); 2. a DGP chosen from the three senior-most officers empanelled by the UPSC, with a two-year minimum tenure; 3. a two-year tenure for IGs, SPs and SHOs; 4. investigation kept separate from law and order, starting in cities of 10 lakh+; 5. a Police Establishment Board (senior officers who decide transfers and postings up to DSP); 6. a Police Complaints Authority at state and district levels; 7. a National Security Commission for central police forces.
-
A new police law: the Model Police Act 2006 (Soli Sorabjee committee) was a draft law to replace the 1861 Act. Many states passed their own Acts that weakened the directives instead.
- Poor compliance: the Justice K.T. Thomas committee (2008-10) found that most states were not following the directives. A 2018 Supreme Court order (3 July) banned "acting" DGPs.
- What it left behind: the NPC is the starting point of the police-reform debate. Its central idea, that police must answer to the law and not to the ruling party, is the core of Prakash Singh.
Don't confuse with
- Shah Commission (1978): it investigated Emergency excesses after they happened. The NPC was a reform body that looked ahead at how policing should be organised.
- Ribeiro, Padmanabhaiah and Malimath committees: these were later reviews that came after the NPC. Malimath looked at the wider criminal justice system, not only the police.
- Model Police Act 2006: this was a draft law by the Soli Sorabjee committee. The NPC produced eight reports, not a model Act from 2006.
- National Security Commission: this is one of the seven Prakash Singh directives, meant for central police forces. Do not mix it up with the National Police Commission of 1977-81.
Prelims Hooks
- National Police Commission: 1977-81, chaired by Dharma Vira, eight reports. It was the first full post-Independence review of policing.
- It came after the Emergency (1975-77). Its reports were largely ignored, as were those of the Ribeiro, Padmanabhaiah and Malimath committees.
- "Police" is Entry 2 and "Public order" is Entry 1 of the State List. They are not in the Concurrent List.
- Prakash Singh (2006): seven directives (State Security Commission, Police Establishment Board, Police Complaints Authority and others). These turned old reform ideas like the NPC's into binding orders.
- Trap: the colonial Police Act 1861 still shapes policing. Neither the NPC nor the Model Police Act 2006 replaced it across India.
Mains Points
- Why good reports fail: the NPC's eight reports and the later committees were ignored because police is a state subject and states did not want to lose control over transfers. This shows that reform needs either political will or a court order, and even court orders (Prakash Singh, 2006) have been only partly followed (K.T. Thomas committee, 2008-10).
- Control vs accountability: the NPC's main question was how to give the police freedom from political interference while keeping them answerable to the law. Prakash Singh tried to strike this balance through State Security Commissions and Police Complaints Authorities. Critics say these bodies are often weak or headed by serving officials.
- Lessons from the Emergency: the NPC and the Shah Commission (1978) together support one point. Police officers should be committed to the Constitution, not to the ruling party, and replacing the colonial Police Act 1861 with a modern law is still unfinished work.