Negative and positive rights
Also called: Negative rights, Positive rights · Topic: Political Theory: Freedom and Rights · NCERT: Beyond NCERT
Meaning
A negative right stops the State from interfering with you. To respect it, the State only has to hold back. Examples are free speech or not being arrested at will. A positive right needs the State to act and provide something, such as education, food or work. In India, Arts. 19-22 work mainly as negative rights because they limit what the State can do. Art. 21A and laws like the RTE Act 2009 and the NFSA 2013 create positive rights. The difference matters because a positive right costs money and needs the State to build systems, while a negative right mostly needs the State to stay out of the way.
Example
Under Art. 22, police cannot hold an arrested person without telling them why. That person must also be brought before a magistrate. This is a negative right because it limits the State. Under Art. 21A, added by the 86th Amendment (2002) and put into effect by the RTE Act 2009, the State must provide free education to children. This is a positive right because the State has to open schools and pay for them.
Don't confuse with
- Negative and positive liberty: Isaiah Berlin (1958) used these terms for two ideas of freedom. One is "freedom from" interference. The other is "freedom to", which means self-mastery. Negative and positive rights are about what the State owes a person: either to hold back or to provide.
- Directive Principles of State Policy (DPSP): DPSPs are goals that courts cannot enforce. A positive right can still be an enforceable Fundamental Right, as Art. 21A is.