Post-retirement appointment of judges
Also called: Cooling-off period for judges · Topic: Judiciary: Independence, Structure, Judicial Review and Activism · NCERT: Beyond NCERT
Meaning
A post-retirement appointment is a new job that a judge takes after retiring. Examples are a seat in a tribunal or a commission, a post in a state government, or a nomination to Parliament. The worry is about judicial independence, which means judges deciding cases without fear or favour. A judge who hopes for such a job might go easy on the government while still on the bench. Even if nothing wrong happens, people may doubt the judge's fairness. A Rajya Sabha committee (2010) warned that judges near retirement were seeking these posts. A parliamentary committee (2013) went further and recommended a cooling-off period, a fixed wait before a new government job, of ten years. India still has no binding rule.
Example
In 2020, former Chief Justice of India Ranjan Gogoi was nominated to the Rajya Sabha. This came soon after he retired, and it started a national debate on whether judges should accept such posts.
Don't confuse with
- Bar on practising law after retirement (Art. 124(7); Art. 220 for High Courts): this is a rule in the Constitution. It stops retired judges from appearing as lawyers in court. It does not stop them from taking government jobs.
- Retired judges sitting in court (Art. 128 for the Supreme Court; Art. 224A for High Courts): here a retired judge comes back to do court work. The Chief Justice asks, and the President consents. The government does not hand out the post as a reward.