Pre-enactment judicial review

Polity & Governance glossary

Also called: Pre-legislative review, Judicial review of Bills · Topic: Judiciary: Independence, Structure, Judicial Review and Activism · NCERT: Beyond NCERT

Meaning

Pre-enactment judicial review means a court checks whether a Bill (a draft law that Parliament has not yet passed) fits the Constitution before it becomes law. Sri Lanka's Supreme Court does this. If the court finds no clash, the Bill goes ahead by ordinary procedure. India has no general system like this. Indian courts can strike down a law only after it is passed, using judicial review under Articles 13, 32 and 226. A finding before a law is passed gives certainty that the law will not be struck down later. Review after it is passed lets courts remove bad parts once they see how the law is actually used.

Example

The closest Indian case is the Kerala Education Bill reference (1958). The President asked the Supreme Court for its opinion on a Bill under Article 143, which lets the President refer a question of law to the Court. The Court's answer was only advice. It did not bind the government, and it did not cancel the Bill.

Don't confuse with

  • Judicial review (in India): it tests laws that are already passed, and it can declare them void. Pre-enactment review tests a Bill before it is passed.
  • Advisory jurisdiction (Article 143): the President chooses whether to refer a question, and the Court "may" decline to answer. Its opinion is not binding, so it is not a veto on the Bill.

Read more