Prior restraint
Also called: Censorship before publication · Topic: Fundamental Rights and Constitutional Remedies · NCERT: Beyond NCERT
Meaning
Prior restraint means the State stops speech or a publication before it reaches the public. This differs from punishing speech after it is out. Examples are a ban on printing or circulating a journal, a rule that content must be cleared first, or a requirement to get permission before posting. In India it is tested under Article 19(1)(a) (freedom of speech and expression, which includes freedom of the press). It is valid only if it fits one of the eight grounds in Article 19(2) and is a reasonable restriction, meaning a limit the courts find fair and not excessive. Courts treat it as one of the harshest limits on speech. The public never hears the words at all, so nobody can judge whether they were actually harmful.
Example
In the Romesh Thappar case (1950), the Madras government banned a journal from entering the state, which stopped it from circulating at all. The Supreme Court struck down the ban because "public safety" was not a ground listed in Article 19(2). This led Parliament to pass the 1st Amendment, 1951, which added "public order" and other grounds.
Don't confuse with
- Post-publication punishment (for example, criminal defamation under BNS s.356 or contempt of court): the speech is allowed out first, and the speaker is punished later if a court finds it unlawful. Prior restraint blocks the speech before anyone sees it.