Public policy exception in arbitration

Polity & Governance glossary

Also called: Public policy ground, Section 48(2)(b) · Topic: Justice Delivery: Subordinate Courts, Tribunals, Legal Aid and Judicial Reforms · NCERT: Beyond NCERT

Meaning

The public policy exception in arbitration lets an Indian court refuse to enforce a foreign arbitral award if enforcing it would go against India's public policy. Here that means the fundamental policy of Indian law, the interests of India, or justice or morality. An award obtained by fraud or corruption also falls under this ground.

It is a narrow safety valve. It protects India's basic legal values, but it does not let Indian courts re-decide the dispute. This is what keeps India trusted as a place where arbitration awards get enforced.

Explanation

What it is and where it sits

  • An arbitral award is the binding decision given by an arbitrator, a neutral person the parties choose instead of going to court.
  • A foreign award is an award made in another country. The "seat" (the legal home of the arbitration) is outside India.
  • Section 48 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 lists the only conditions on which India can refuse to enforce a foreign award.
  • Section 48 has seven grounds in total:
  • Five under S.48(1). The losing party must raise and prove these.
  • Two under S.48(2). The court can apply these on its own: non-arbitrability (the subject cannot legally be settled by arbitration) and public policy.

  • The public policy ground is S.48(2)(b).

The test: when public policy applies

  • Enforcement can be refused only if the award is contrary to one of three things: 1. the fundamental policy of Indian law; 2. the interests of India; 3. justice or morality.

  • Fraud or corruption: an award induced by fraud or corruption conflicts with India's public policy. This comes from the Explanation to S.48.

  • If the award passes this test and the other grounds, it is enforced. It is then "deemed to be a decree" of the Indian court, so it can be executed like a court's own order.

Limits: what it does NOT allow

  • No review on the merits. The enforcing court cannot decide afresh who was right on the facts or on the contract.
  • A mere breach of a statute is not enough. Breaking some law, without more, does not attract the public-policy bar.
  • No setting aside. Only the court at the seat can set aside (cancel) a foreign award. An Indian court can only refuse to enforce it in India.
  • The test is the same for domestic and foreign awards. After the 2016 amendment (Act 3 of 2016), the public policy ground is identical under S.34 and S.48.
  • No special treatment for the government. The law on enforcing an arbitral award is the same for the State as for any private party.

In the Constitution and practice

  • The law: Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996, based on the UNCITRAL Model Law (a model arbitration law prepared by the UN).
  • Part I covers domestic arbitration. An award there is enforced like a decree (s.36) and can be set aside only on narrow grounds (s.34).
  • Part II covers foreign awards. Section 48 sets the grounds for refusing enforcement.

  • International source: S.48 mirrors Article V of the New York Convention.

  • Article V(1) lists the grounds the party resisting enforcement must prove.
  • Article V(2) lists public policy, which the court can apply on its own motion.
  • Reciprocity: India enforces awards made in other New York Convention countries, and those countries enforce awards made in India.

  • Amendments:

  • 2015 (Act 3 of 2016): made the public policy ground identical under S.34 and S.48. It also brought in timelines.
  • 2019: set up the Arbitration Council of India.
  • 2021: allowed an automatic stay (pause) on an award where fraud is shown.

  • Key judgments:

  • 2024 INSC 242 (4 March 2024): the enforcing court cannot review the merits.
  • 2026 INSC 298 (25 March 2026): a mere breach of a statute does not meet the public-policy bar, and the ground is the same under S.34 and S.48.
  • DMRC case: the law on enforcing an award is no different for the government.

  • Who uses it: usually the losing party, often the government or a PSU, resisting a foreign award at the enforcement stage. Courts have read the ground narrowly so it cannot be used to reopen lost cases.

  • Why it matters for India: India wants to be an arbitration hub, with the India International Arbitration Centre (set up by a 2019 Act, renamed in 2022). Using the public policy ground too widely would hurt investor trust. In 2021 Cairn Energy dropped its cases against India after accepting an offer of about $1 bn.

Don't confuse with

  • Setting aside an award (S.34): this cancels a domestic award (Part I). S.48 only refuses enforcement of a foreign award in India. Only the seat court can cancel a foreign award.
  • Review on the merits: an appeal-like re-examination of facts and contract terms. The public policy exception expressly does not allow this.
  • Non-arbitrability (S.48(2)(a)): the other ground a court may apply on its own. It asks whether the subject can legally go to arbitration at all. Public policy asks whether enforcing this award offends India's basic legal values.
  • Grounds under S.48(1): the five grounds the losing party must prove. Public policy sits in S.48(2), which the court can raise itself.

Prelims Hooks

  • Enforcement of foreign awards → Section 48, Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996. Public policy → S.48(2)(b).
  • S.48 has seven grounds: five in S.48(1) (proved by a party) and two in S.48(2) (court on its own: non-arbitrability and public policy).
  • Three limbs of the public policy test: fundamental policy of Indian law, interests of India, justice or morality. Fraud or corruption also attracts it.
  • Act 3 of 2016 made the public policy ground identical under S.34 and S.48.
  • S.48 mirrors Article V of the New York Convention. An enforceable foreign award is deemed a decree.
  • Trap: "Under the public policy ground an Indian court can review the merits of a foreign award, or refuse it for any breach of a statute": FALSE.

Mains Points

  • Sovereignty vs credibility:
  • The ground lets India refuse awards that offend its core legal values or were won by fraud.
  • Reading it too widely would undo the New York Convention bargain of reciprocity and hurt India's ambition to be an arbitration hub.
  • Courts have struck the balance by banning merits review and rejecting "mere breach of statute" objections.

  • The State as a litigant:

  • Governments and PSUs often raise public policy just to delay paying.
  • The SC has said the law on enforcing an award is the same for the government.
  • Officials appeal by default because they fear vigilance enquiries if they settle.
  • Reforms: screen appeals before filing them, protect good-faith decisions not to appeal, and use settlement schemes such as Vivad se Vishwas II (Budget 2023-24).

  • Preventing disputes at the source:

  • The Standing Committee recommended making the IIAC the designated forum in government contracts.
  • The SC has ruled that PSUs cannot appoint arbitrators on their own.
  • Fair, institutional processes leave fewer genuine public policy objections. This supports contract enforcement and ease of doing business.

Read more