Public trust doctrine

Polity & Governance glossary

Topic: Judiciary: Independence, Structure, Judicial Review and Activism · NCERT: Beyond NCERT

Meaning

The public trust doctrine is the principle that the State holds natural resources such as rivers, forests, the sea, minerals and gas as a trustee for the people. A trustee looks after property on behalf of others and does not own it for itself.

This matters because the State cannot treat these resources as its own private property. It cannot give them away cheaply or unfairly. It must use and share them for the good of all the people, including people not yet born.

Explanation

How the idea works

  • The three parties:
  • The people are the real beneficiaries (those for whose benefit the resource is kept).
  • The State is only the trustee. It manages the resource.
  • The resource is the trust property. It must be protected, not wasted.

  • What the trustee must do:

  • Protect the resource from damage and misuse.
  • Share access to it fairly, not to favour a few.
  • Get a fair return when it gives the resource to private firms, because that money belongs to the public.

  • Where the idea comes from: an old Roman law idea that some things, such as air, running water, the sea and the seashore, are common to everyone and cannot be privately owned.

A judge-made doctrine

  • Like judicial review, the doctrine is not named in the Constitution. Courts built it by reading several provisions together (see the next section).
  • It mostly reaches courts through public interest litigation (PIL), which means a case filed for a public cause under Art. 32 or Art. 226. The environmental PILs in the M.C. Mehta cases (oleum gas leak, Ganga pollution, Taj Trapezium, Delhi's air) belong to the same tradition of courts guarding shared resources.
  • Courts use it as a test of State action. If a government decision hands over a public resource unfairly, or lets it be damaged, the court can strike the decision down.

Limits

  • It does not stop the State from using resources. It only requires that the use serves the common good.
  • It does not tell the government which method to use, such as auction or contract. That is a policy choice, but the choice must be fair and reasoned.
  • It applies most clearly to natural resources. Courts have to decide case by case how far it stretches.

In the Constitution and practice

  • Constitutional anchors (the doctrine rests on these, though none of them names it):
  • Art. 39(b) (a Directive Principle): the ownership and control of the community's material resources should be shared out to serve the common good.
  • Art. 297: lands, minerals and other things of value under the ocean, within India's territorial waters, continental shelf or exclusive economic zone, vest in the Union. Offshore gas, like that in the Krishna-Godavari (KG) basin, falls here.
  • Art. 48A (added by the 42nd Amendment, 1976): the State shall protect the environment, forests and wildlife.
  • Art. 51A(g): citizens have a fundamental duty to protect the natural environment.
  • Art. 21: courts have widened the right to life to cover dignity and a healthy life, and environmental cases build on this.

  • The 2012 Natural Resources Allocation Reference: the Supreme Court said natural resources are held in public trust. This was the Court's advisory opinion to the President under Art. 143 [UV].

  • KG basin gas dispute (Delhi High Court, February 2025):
  • Justices Rekha Palli and Saurabh Banerjee set aside the 2018 arbitral award that had gone in favour of Reliance Industries Ltd (RIL).
  • They found patent illegality (an obvious legal error on the face of the award). They also held the award was against public policy and the public trust doctrine. Their reasoning was that gas under the seabed belongs to the people, not to the government of the day.
  • RIL appealed to the Supreme Court. In October 2026 the Supreme Court sent the dispute to mediation under Justice Ranjana Prakash Desai, with help from two domain experts.

  • The doctrine in a settlement:

  • Under the Mediation Act, 2023, a government party can sign a settlement only after the competent authority (the officer or body legally empowered to approve) gives prior written consent. What is said during mediation stays confidential.
  • The Supreme Court kept the case on its list, so a failed mediation goes back to the Court for a decision.

Don't confuse with

  • Art. 297 (vesting in the Union): Art. 297 says who holds offshore resources (the Union). The public trust doctrine says how the holder must act: as a trustee for the people, not as an owner free to do as it likes.
  • Absolute liability (M.C. Mehta, 1987): this is a rule about a private firm's full liability for harm caused by its hazardous work. The public trust doctrine is a duty placed on the State to guard shared resources.
  • Eminent domain: the State's power to take private property for a public purpose. Public trust is about resources that are already public and that the State must protect.
  • Art. 39(b): a Directive Principle, so courts cannot enforce it on its own. The public trust doctrine is a judge-made rule that courts do apply to strike down State action.

Prelims Hooks

  • The public trust doctrine is not named in the Constitution. Courts drew it from Arts. 21, 39(b), 48A and 51A(g). This makes it a "which of the following is expressly mentioned" trap.
  • Art. 297: minerals and things of value in the territorial waters, continental shelf and exclusive economic zone vest in the Union, not the states.
  • 2012 Natural Resources Allocation Reference: an advisory opinion under Art. 143. Such opinions do not bind the government [UV].
  • Art. 48A (protecting the environment) was added by the 42nd Amendment, 1976. Art. 51A(g) makes protecting nature a citizen's duty.
  • Delhi High Court Division Bench (February 2025): relied on patent illegality, public policy and the public trust doctrine to set aside the KG basin arbitral award.

Mains Points

  • Judicial creativity vs separation of powers:
  • The doctrine lets courts stop unfair handovers of public wealth, filling gaps when the government fails to act.
  • Critics say it lets judges question policy choices, such as pricing or contracts, that belong to the elected government. This links to the wider debate on judicial overreach.

  • Public trust vs contract sanctity:

  • Using the doctrine to cancel a commercial award protects the public purse.
  • It can also make investors less sure that contracts with the State will be honoured. Exploration contracts should spell out fair terms and how disputes will be settled when they are written, so courts need not step in later.

  • Transparency in settling public resource claims:

  • Mediation is confidential. So a claim the courts linked to the people's resources may be settled without public reasons being given.
  • A balanced fix: keep the talks confidential, but put the settlement terms and their reasons on record before the Supreme Court. Settlements should also need competent-authority approval and be backed by expert evidence.

Read more