Reiteration of collegium recommendation

Polity & Governance glossary

Also called: Reiterated names · Topic: Judiciary: Independence, Structure, Judicial Review and Activism · NCERT: Beyond NCERT

Meaning

A reiteration happens when the collegium (the group of senior-most judges who choose judges) sends the same name to the government a second time. Under the collegium system, which grew out of the Second Judges case (SCAORA, 1993), the government may send a recommended name back once, asking the collegium to think again. If the collegium sends that name again, the government is bound to appoint the person. This rule keeps final control over appointments with the judiciary, which the Supreme Court treats as part of independence of the judiciary.

Example

The government has often sat on names for a long time, even reiterated ones, without formally rejecting them. This is a major point of friction between the government and the judiciary. In PLR Projects (2021), the Supreme Court set timelines for the government to act on names. Even so, the 1999 Memorandum of Procedure (the rulebook for appointments) has no binding deadline, so a delay can work like a silent veto.

Don't confuse with

  • President returning a Bill (Art. 111): The President can send an ordinary Bill back to Parliament once. If Parliament passes it again, the President must give assent. That rule is written in the Constitution. The rule on reiterated names is not written there: judges made it, and it covers appointments, not laws.
  • Consultation vs concurrence: These terms describe who has the final say in an appointment. Reiteration is the step that puts that final say into action when the government objects.

Read more