Transfer of criminal cases

Polity & Governance glossary

Also called: Section 446 BNSS, Section 406 CrPC · Topic: Justice Delivery: Subordinate Courts, Tribunals, Legal Aid and Judicial Reforms · NCERT: Beyond NCERT

Meaning

Transfer of criminal cases is the Supreme Court's power, under Section 446 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita (BNSS) 2023 (earlier Section 406 of the CrPC 1973), to move a criminal case or appeal from one State to another. It can move the case from one High Court to another High Court. It can also move it from a criminal court under one High Court to a court of equal or higher rank under another High Court. It does this when the move is "expedient for the ends of justice", which means it is needed so that justice is done.

This power protects the right to a fair trial, which comes from Article 21. It is used when a trial in the home State may not be fair, for example because of a hostile local atmosphere, threats to witnesses, or strong political pressure.

Explanation

How it works

  • Who can ask:
  • The Attorney-General of India, or
  • any "party interested", such as the accused, the complainant or the victim.
  • The Supreme Court does not use this power on its own under this section. Someone must apply.

  • How to apply: the applicant files a motion (a formal written request) in the Supreme Court.

  • It must be backed by an affidavit, a sworn written statement of facts.
  • The Attorney-General and a State's Advocate-General do not need an affidavit.

  • What the Court can order:

  • It can move a particular case or appeal from one High Court to another.
  • It can move it from a criminal court under one High Court to a criminal court of equal or higher jurisdiction (the area and type of cases a court can hear) under another High Court.

  • Misuse is punished: if the Court finds the application frivolous (without any real basis) or vexatious (filed only to harass), it can order the applicant to pay compensation to the other side.

The test: "ends of justice"

  • The law does not list fixed grounds. The single test is whether a transfer is needed for justice to be done.
  • Courts accept a "reasonable apprehension" of bias as a ground. This means a fear of unfairness that a sensible person would share, not just the fear the accused feels. Courts have set a high bar for it.
  • Factors courts usually weigh:
  • A hostile or communally charged atmosphere in the State.
  • Threats to the accused, the victim or the witnesses.
  • Witnesses being pressured, or changing their testimony.
  • Where the witnesses and documents are, and how much the move will cost the parties in time and travel.

  • Against transfer:

  • The presumption that judges are independent. Courts start from the view that a trial judge will not bend to local speeches or pressure.
  • The right to a speedy trial, which Hussainara Khatoon (1979) made part of Article 21. Moving a trial adds delay.

Limits and what it is not

  • It is only for moving cases between States. If the trial stays inside the same State, the High Court moves it under a separate BNSS provision. Inside a district, the Sessions Judge does so.
  • It is a last resort. The Court can choose lighter remedies instead:
  • restraining public comment on the case,
  • protecting witnesses (Witness Protection Scheme 2018, Mahender Chawla; BNSS s.398 makes States notify such schemes),
  • keeping the matter under its own watch.

  • Old law and new law: the new criminal laws came into force on 1 July 2024. Offences committed before that date stay under the old laws, so older cases still cite Section 406 CrPC.

In the Constitution and practice

  • Constitutional root:
  • Article 21 (right to life and personal liberty) covers a fair and speedy trial.
  • Article 50 keeps the judiciary separate from the executive. This is why a court, not the government, decides where a trial happens.

  • Statutory source:

  • Section 406, CrPC 1973 was replaced by Section 446, BNSS 2023.
  • The BNSS (531 sections) was passed in December 2023 and replaced the CrPC.

  • Who uses it: the Supreme Court, because only it sits above all the High Courts. No single State's High Court can send a case into another State.

  • The related constitutional route:
  • Article 139A was added by the 42nd Amendment (1976).
  • It lets the Supreme Court take over cases from High Courts that involve the same important questions of law.
  • It also lets the Court move cases between High Courts.
  • It is not the usual route for moving a criminal trial. That route is BNSS s.446.

  • How it works in practice (example):

  • On 5 November 2026, a Bench headed by CJI Surya Kant refused to move the Tirupati laddu ghee adulteration trial out of Andhra Pradesh. The plea was filed by an accused who said the State's atmosphere was "politically charged".
  • The Court pointed out that a Central agency (CBI) was handling the probe. It restrained public comment instead and allowed the accused to come back if problems arose.
  • What this shows: political remarks alone rarely meet the "ends of justice" test. The Court prefers lighter remedies first.

Don't confuse with

  • Article 139A: a constitutional power, mainly about questions of law common to cases in several High Courts. BNSS s.446 is the ordinary statutory route for moving a criminal trial between States.
  • High Court's power of transfer: used within one State, to move a case from one court to another under the same High Court. Interstate transfer belongs only to the Supreme Court.
  • Zero FIR (BNSS s.173): a police station registers an FIR and sends it to the police station that has jurisdiction. That is a police step at the investigation stage. Transfer of a criminal case is a court's order about where the trial takes place.
  • Transfer of civil cases: done under the Code of Civil Procedure, not the BNSS.

Prelims Hooks

  • The Supreme Court's power to transfer criminal cases between States is in Section 446 of the BNSS 2023 (formerly Section 406 CrPC).
  • Who can apply: only the Attorney-General of India or a party interested. The Court does not start it on its own under this section.
  • The legal test is "expedient for the ends of justice", not "a fair trial is impossible". A mere allegation of bias is not enough. There must be a reasonable apprehension.
  • Trap: "Article 139A is the main route for moving a criminal trial to another State": FALSE. Article 139A (42nd Amendment, 1976) deals mainly with common questions of law. Criminal trials move under BNSS s.446.
  • Trap: "A High Court can move a criminal trial to a court in another State": FALSE. Only the Supreme Court can do this.
  • The fair-trial link: the right to a fair and speedy trial is part of Article 21 (Hussainara Khatoon, 1979, on speedy trial).

Mains Points

  • Fair trial vs speedy trial:
  • Transfer protects the accused, the victim and the witnesses from local pressure.
  • But it moves the trial away from where the witnesses and records are. This adds delay and cost, and delay is itself a denial of justice under Article 21.
  • So courts keep the bar high and treat transfer as a last resort.

  • Lighter remedies first:

  • Gag orders on public comment, witness protection (Mahender Chawla, 2018; BNSS s.398) and court monitoring can protect a trial without moving it.
  • Their weakness is enforcement. If office-holders keep commenting on a case still in court (sub judice), the case for transfer gets stronger.

  • Trust in the subordinate judiciary:

  • Frequent transfers would suggest that a State's courts cannot resist local politics. This would undermine the separation of the judiciary from the executive (Article 50).
  • Long-term reforms reduce the need for transfers: an independent prosecution (BNSS s.20 Directorate of Prosecution), strong witness protection, and the 2nd ARC's Fifth Report (2007).

Read more