Balancing the State's interest in recovering public money with the individual's right to liberty is a recurring challenge in economic-offence cases. Discuss.
New · District CollectorCan you hold the district for 72 hours?Floods, a heatwave, an outbreak, a grievance queue. Take the decisions, see the consequences.Play →In this answer
Under Article 21, any restriction on travel must follow a fair, just and reasonable "procedure established by law" (Maneka Gandhi, 1978) [7]. Yet Look-Out Circulars (LOCs), a key tool against fleeing economic offenders, rest only on executive memoranda. Tina Ambani's recent Delhi High Court plea, which asks merely to learn whether an LOC exists against her [1], shows the tension sharply.
State's interest: why restraint is needed
- Flight risk: high-value bank-fraud accused left India, which led to the Fugitive Economic Offenders Act, 2018, covering offences of ₹100 crore or more [4].
- Scale of enforcement: ED opened 775 new PMLA investigations and filed 333 prosecution complaints in FY 2024-25 [5]. Restraints keep accused persons and assets within reach.
- Recovering bank dues: in 2018, MHA allowed public sector bank chairmen, MDs and CEOs to request LOCs [2].
- Secrecy: telling a suspect in advance can defeat the purpose of the LOC.
Individual's liberty: why concern persists
- No statutory backing: LOCs flow from MHA Office Memoranda that can be changed overnight, as the 2018 amendment showed [2].
- Arbitrariness: in Viraj Chetan Shah (2024), the Bombay High Court struck down the bank clause as violating Articles 14 and 21 [3].
- Opacity: people often discover an LOC only at the airport. They get no reasons, no review date and no clear forum.
- Multiple agencies: the SIT on Black Money urged the SFIO to refer money-laundering cases to the ED [6]. This helps coordination but creates parallel proceedings, which is why one plea named three respondents [1].
- Family members: relatives of promoters can face restrictions even though liability is personal.
Striking the balance
- A statutory LOC law with defined grounds, minimum default thresholds and time-bound review. The FEO Act's model, where a special court decides [4], is a template.
- Recorded, reasoned orders that name the agency which requested the LOC.
- Disclosure after issuance, in a sealed cover to the court where needed.
- Proportionality: allow travel against a surety or bank guarantee instead of a blanket ban.
Economic offences drain public resources, but investigative convenience cannot cost citizens their liberty. A legislated, proportionate and reviewable LOC regime would protect the exchequer while meeting Article 21's guarantee of fair procedure [7]. That would serve both the State's interest in recovery and the constitutional promise of liberty.
Sources
- 1HC seeks ED's stand on Tina Ambani's plea, The Hindu, 20 Nov 2026Delhi High Court notice to Bureau of Immigration, ED and SFIO on LOC-disclosure plea
- 2MHA reply, Lok Sabha Unstarred Question No. 1317 (18 Dec 2018)2018 amendment letting PSB chiefs request LOCs
- 3Bombay High Court, *Viraj Chetan Shah v. Union of India*, judgment dated 23 Apr 2024PSB clause in LOC Office Memorandum struck down under Articles 14 and 21
- 4PIB: Cabinet approves Fugitive Economic Offenders Bill, 2018₹100 crore threshold; special court under PMLA declares a fugitive
- 5Enforcement Directorate Annual Report FY 2024-25775 new PMLA investigations, 333 prosecution complaints
- 6PIB: Recommendations of SIT on Black Money as Contained in the Third SIT ReportSFIO to refer money-laundering cases to ED
- 7Supreme Court of India, *Maneka Gandhi v. Union of India* (1978)restriction on travel requires a fair, just and reasonable procedure established by law