·The Hindu·15 marks·250–350 wordsPolityEconomy

Balancing the State's interest in recovering public money with the individual's right to liberty is a recurring challenge in economic-offence cases. Discuss.

New · District CollectorCan you hold the district for 72 hours?Floods, a heatwave, an outbreak, a grievance queue. Take the decisions, see the consequences.Play →
In this answer
  1. State's interest: why restraint is needed
  2. Individual's liberty: why concern persists
  3. Striking the balance

Under Article 21, any restriction on travel must follow a fair, just and reasonable "procedure established by law" (Maneka Gandhi, 1978) [7]. Yet Look-Out Circulars (LOCs), a key tool against fleeing economic offenders, rest only on executive memoranda. Tina Ambani's recent Delhi High Court plea, which asks merely to learn whether an LOC exists against her [1], shows the tension sharply.

State's interest: why restraint is needed

  • Flight risk: high-value bank-fraud accused left India, which led to the Fugitive Economic Offenders Act, 2018, covering offences of ₹100 crore or more [4].
  • Scale of enforcement: ED opened 775 new PMLA investigations and filed 333 prosecution complaints in FY 2024-25 [5]. Restraints keep accused persons and assets within reach.
  • Recovering bank dues: in 2018, MHA allowed public sector bank chairmen, MDs and CEOs to request LOCs [2].
  • Secrecy: telling a suspect in advance can defeat the purpose of the LOC.

Individual's liberty: why concern persists

  • No statutory backing: LOCs flow from MHA Office Memoranda that can be changed overnight, as the 2018 amendment showed [2].
  • Arbitrariness: in Viraj Chetan Shah (2024), the Bombay High Court struck down the bank clause as violating Articles 14 and 21 [3].
  • Opacity: people often discover an LOC only at the airport. They get no reasons, no review date and no clear forum.
  • Multiple agencies: the SIT on Black Money urged the SFIO to refer money-laundering cases to the ED [6]. This helps coordination but creates parallel proceedings, which is why one plea named three respondents [1].
  • Family members: relatives of promoters can face restrictions even though liability is personal.

Striking the balance

  • A statutory LOC law with defined grounds, minimum default thresholds and time-bound review. The FEO Act's model, where a special court decides [4], is a template.
  • Recorded, reasoned orders that name the agency which requested the LOC.
  • Disclosure after issuance, in a sealed cover to the court where needed.
  • Proportionality: allow travel against a surety or bank guarantee instead of a blanket ban.

Economic offences drain public resources, but investigative convenience cannot cost citizens their liberty. A legislated, proportionate and reviewable LOC regime would protect the exchequer while meeting Article 21's guarantee of fair procedure [7]. That would serve both the State's interest in recovery and the constitutional promise of liberty.

Sources

  1. 1HC seeks ED's stand on Tina Ambani's plea, The Hindu, 20 Nov 2026Delhi High Court notice to Bureau of Immigration, ED and SFIO on LOC-disclosure plea
  2. 2MHA reply, Lok Sabha Unstarred Question No. 1317 (18 Dec 2018)2018 amendment letting PSB chiefs request LOCs
  3. 3Bombay High Court, *Viraj Chetan Shah v. Union of India*, judgment dated 23 Apr 2024PSB clause in LOC Office Memorandum struck down under Articles 14 and 21
  4. 4PIB: Cabinet approves Fugitive Economic Offenders Bill, 2018₹100 crore threshold; special court under PMLA declares a fugitive
  5. 5Enforcement Directorate Annual Report FY 2024-25775 new PMLA investigations, 333 prosecution complaints
  6. 6PIB: Recommendations of SIT on Black Money as Contained in the Third SIT ReportSFIO to refer money-laundering cases to ED
  7. 7Supreme Court of India, *Maneka Gandhi v. Union of India* (1978)restriction on travel requires a fair, just and reasonable procedure established by law
Practice
5 questions on this article
Check the answer for each question, or reveal all at once.
Practice MCQs →

More from this note

More on Polity