Look-Out Circulars are an effective investigative tool but lack a statutory basis and procedural safeguards. Critically examine in light of Article 21.
New · District CollectorCan you hold the district for 72 hours?Floods, a heatwave, an outbreak, a grievance queue. Take the decisions, see the consequences.Play →A Look-Out Circular (LOC) is an alert, enforced by the Bureau of Immigration, that lets authorities stop a person at the border [1]. It rests on MHA Office Memoranda, not on an Act of Parliament [2]. Since Maneka Gandhi (1978), the right to travel abroad has been part of Article 21. It can be restricted only by a "procedure established by law" that is fair, just and reasonable. LOCs are useful, but they currently fall short of that standard.
LOCs as an effective tool
- Prevents flight: the CBI and the ED issued LOCs against Nirav Modi and Mehul Choksi in the bank-fraud case [3]. Escapes by accused offenders led to the Fugitive Economic Offenders Act, 2018.
- Quick and less intrusive than arrest: it flags a person at immigration points without taking them into custody, and it keeps the investigation confidential.
- Accepted by courts: even the Bombay HC struck down only the bank clause, not the LOC system [4].
Deficits when tested against Article 21
- No statute: an OM can be changed overnight. The 2018 amendment let chiefs of public sector banks request LOCs to protect the "economic interests of India" [2].
- Judicial rebuke: in April 2024 the Bombay HC struck down this bank clause as arbitrary and violative of Articles 14 and 21 [4].
- No notice or reasons: people usually learn of an LOC at the airport. Tina Ambani had to make the Bureau of Immigration, ED and SFIO respondents just to learn whether an LOC existed [1].
- No thresholds or review: there is no minimum default amount, no fixed validity period and no forum to challenge an LOC. This weakens the "fair procedure" test.
Way forward
- Parliament should pass an LOC law with judicial oversight, on the lines of the FEOA, 2018.
- Grounds should be codified, with written reasons and periodic review or sunset clauses.
- Disclosure after issuance, in a sealed cover to the court if needed, would protect secrecy before a person can flee while still allowing a challenge.
- The Bureau should record which agency requested each LOC, so the person knows whom to approach.
LOCs serve a legitimate aim, but resting them on executive orders alone strains Article 21. A clear statute with safeguards would keep the tool effective and also meet the constitutional promise of fair procedure.
Sources
- 1HC seeks ED's stand on Tina Ambani's plea — The Hindu, 20 Nov 2026the Bureau of Immigration enforces LOCs; the plea names the Bureau, ED and SFIO and seeks disclosure of any LOC
- 2MHA reply, Lok Sabha Unstarred Question No. 1317 (18 Dec 2018), "Issuance of Look-Out Notices"LOC guidelines amended by MHA; PSB chiefs allowed to request LOCs
- 3MHA reply, Rajya Sabha Question No. 2943 (21 Mar 2018): LOCs against Nirav Modi and Mehul ChoksiCBI and ED LOCs in the bank-fraud case
- 4Bombay High Court, *Viraj Chetan Shah v. Union of India*, WP No. 719 of 2020 (23 Apr 2024)bank clause in the LOC OM struck down; the rest of the OM kept
Practice
5 questions on this article
Check the answer for each question, or reveal all at once.