·The Hindu·15 marks·250–350 wordsPolityIR

Coalition politics in fragmented legislatures often gives disproportionate leverage to smaller parties. Discuss with examples from India and abroad.

New · District CollectorCan you hold the district for 72 hours?Floods, a heatwave, an outbreak, a grievance queue. Take the decisions, see the consequences.Play →
In this answer
  1. How smaller parties gain leverage
  2. Positive side
  3. Negative side
  4. Way forward

When no party wins a majority, a small party whose seats can tip the balance gains bargaining power far beyond its vote share. It becomes a "kingmaker". Israel's Knesset in November 2026 and India's post-2024 coalition show that this leverage can serve democracy but can also distort it.

How smaller parties gain leverage

  • Pivotal arithmetic: In Israel's 120-member Knesset, opposition candidate Matan Kahana won the Speakership 66–52. He won only because Arab-led parties voted with the Jewish-led opposition, in the first floor test after the 27 October 2026 election [1].
  • Agenda control: That win gave the new majority control of the House. Reports called it a key step towards rolling back the outgoing Netanyahu government's policies [1].
  • Resource bargaining: After 2024, the BJP-led government depended on allies such as the TDP and JD(U). Union Budget 2024-25 then promised ₹15,000 crore for Andhra Pradesh's capital. It also announced road, power and flood-control projects for Bihar [2].
  • Threat of exit: In 1999, the Vajpayee government lost a confidence vote by a single vote after the AIADMK withdrew support.

Positive side

  • Voice for minorities and regions: Groups that would otherwise be sidelined, such as Arab-led parties in Israel, gain a say in national outcomes [1]. In India, regional parties bring state concerns to the Union and strengthen cooperative federalism.
  • Consensus-building: Coalition partners have to negotiate. The Common Minimum Programme model is an example of this moderating effect.

Negative side

  • Skewed allocation: Demands tied to a single state can pull national resources away from need-based criteria. Critics raised this concern about the 2024 packages [2].
  • Instability and horse-trading: Ministerial posts get traded for support. The 91st Amendment (2003) therefore capped the size of the Union Council of Ministers at 15% of the Lok Sabha's strength and tightened the Tenth Schedule.
  • Governance delays: Even after winning the Speaker vote, Eisenkot still had up to five more weeks to form a government [1]. A majority for one vote does not guarantee a stable government.

Way forward

  • Agree on a written Common Minimum Programme and set up coordination committees.
  • Route special transfers to states through rule-based channels such as the Finance Commission (Art. 280).
  • Keep the Speaker neutral and decide anti-defection cases quickly.

Overall, small parties' leverage is a natural result of representing a diverse electorate. Strong institutions can turn it from bargaining over favours into a check on the majority. This keeps coalition politics in line with the constitutional ideals of federalism and unity in diversity.

Sources

  1. 1Israeli Parliament elects new Knesset Speaker backed by Netanyahu's opponents, The Hindu/AP, Nov 202666–52 vote, Arab-led parties' support, 27 Oct election, rollback of policies, five-week window for coalition formation
  2. 2Union Budget 2024-25 Speech, Ministry of Finance₹15,000 crore support for Andhra Pradesh and infrastructure projects for Bihar
Practice
8 questions on this article
Check the answer for each question, or reveal all at once.
Practice MCQs →

More from this note

More on Polity